music, movement, math, combining the challenging with the popular
stories, smiles, walking, experimental music, neuroscience, myth, silence, light, organization of information
spinning poi
I'm currently interning in social media marketing for my local TEDx conference - TEDx Golden Gate ED - which is all about teaching compassion, from all the different sides you can think to approach that topic. I'm very excited to see this conference develop, hopefully becoming an annual event that is surrounded by a community that discusses and acts year round, world round.
09:12 Posted: Jul 2007
Views: 1,215,997 | Comments: 205
TEDCred score: +1.90 TEDCred reflects your contribution to the TED community.
A reply on Conversation: What if the TED Community worked together to build the model 21st century learning environment? What would it look like?
Recently the idea of placing the burden of engagement on the teachers rather than the students was floated by me. In this approach educators design their curriculum to be as irresistibly engaging as possible, and students always have the ability to opt out and work on something they want to do. (This is in stark contrast to much of our current system,where students must force themselves to pay attention to whatever is being presented to them, or pay for it on the test.)
This approach seems that it would reward a nice balance of theory and practice, using the 'authentic context' as Scott put it to personalize to each class and/or even every student. Student input on the path of study is important to keep them interested, and the teacher is actively building the education to match, rather than just following some set plan.
A side note: This style may get rid of the 'base of knowledge' that we all supposedly come out of school knowing, but as long as that is acknowledged/accepted, then I don't think there is a problem (especially since it is already true).
A reply on Talk: Maya Beiser(s) and her cello(s)
1. Yes you are entitled to your opinion. Just know it is your own.
2. Yes, many people know overdubbing is an old technique. But it is not often used in a live setting (every day this is less and less true), nor in the classical tradition (ditto), and it does, as she says in her talk (~8:40), give to opportunity to hear a piece with a different drive than we usually do - rather than many musicians trying to share a concept, it is all born from one. This gives a different feel to the interlocking&interaction of the parts (or it is my opinion that it can). Perhaps it is not about the technology, it is about how it is used.
3. You covered this in 1, except this time you might be projecting your opinion onto the audience and/or dissing them.
4. You have to take her actions as authentic and genuine, unless you have good reason to think otherwise. Her performance was full of expressive movement, so this 'big gesture' seems consistent. It would be worse if she faked humility. This is her art (passion!), unless she gives you reason not to, take it (all!) as authentic.
A reply on Conversation: What if the TED Community worked together to build the model 21st century learning environment? What would it look like?
Taking student input to direct the course of study could be the future. This guarantees the learners will be engaged with the material, since the want to learn it. Of course being the educator, knowing what you know beyond what the kids know, you can steer the inquiry to some extent, and introduce possible new avenues of study.
The first challenge is to start with something that the learners find irresistible, that they want to start engaging with [and always allow them to opt out, to have a quiet space where they can explore something for themselves - this is a new idea I've been considering]. Once they're in, its a cooperative of leading and following [like an ouiji board, haha] between learner and educator, to find a path through whatever topic was begun.
A reply on Conversation: What if the TED Community worked together to build the model 21st century learning environment? What would it look like?
Blended learning does seem to be the way to go here, mixing not only academic subjects, but also emotional and social learning. It's a major shift to our normal, categorization-focused approach, and will take some work to re-orient the thinking of the staff of such a school. I think one key thing is to treat children as capable and intelligent, with ideas worth listening to, not just kids who will sit there and learn what one has to say. Not having a system with right and wrong answers, and with set grades, etc, with a focus on book-academic-intelligence is a big change too, but I think it's the way to go as well. It requires teachers to be really engaged: they can't just phone it in with a lesson plan from 4 years ago, instead they have to actively engage and be engaged by the students, constantly adapting to the children around them.
Also, I totally agree that our system stinks and anything we do will be better; that fear is not my own, but one I suspect some parents will have. However, I have seen that there are enough parents who agree with our view to make these 'new schools' work. And once others see their success, any fear will be dissuaded. Oh, and 'disruptive' deployment is almost certainly the way to go. Of course, as we have said, he problem is replicating the success...
Finally, I'm sure many of you ave seen it, but this RSAnimate, based on a talk by Sir Ken Robinson, was, and still is, a major inspiration for me: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZFcDGpL4U
A reply on Conversation: What if the TED Community worked together to build the model 21st century learning environment? What would it look like?
Finances I can't speak too, but I would like to say this about people: the fear I would have is that parents would not want to risk their children's future, gambling them in some untested, non-traditional form of education. I imagine parents asking questions such as "Will the kids learn all that is important?" and "Will they be able to function at the next level of schooling?". As it turns out, (in the case of the communities where these schools/programs exist) there are plenty of parents who feel as we do, that the existing educational system is broken and they are looking for one of these out-of-the-box initiatives. So as long as the parents and the new-school school connect, people are no problem.
A comment on Conversation: Share: What are your rules for making more happiness in your life?
Whenever you think of it, and think of it often, no matter what is happening.
A comment on Conversation: What if the TED Community worked together to build the model 21st century learning environment? What would it look like?
First, SF Brightworks announced its existence, it's space, and more. Brightworks is a totally different take on the education model - different subjects are quite integrated and the kids direct the flow of things with their passion. Here's a link to their website linking to one of their TEDx talks: http://sfbrightworks.org/blog/2011/05/20/tedxeast/
I almost thought such a radical move wasn't possible because I hadn't seen it happen. Thumbs up to the "Game School" Quest to Learn, where game designers are behind the curriculum again hoping to get kids passionate about learning. (I see the tag "games as educational tools up there".)
The other thing is an upcoming TEDx conference in the Bay Area, California. I'm doing some social media marketing for them, and in the process learning a lot about ways people are trying to integrate compassion into education - a topic we focused on this week in fact on our Facebook page (which I have to link to, since I'm doing social media marketing: https://www.facebook.com/TEDxGoldenGateED ). One of my favourites is the Roots of Empathy program which brings infants and mothers into the classroom periodically over the school year, allowing the students to connect with this tiny being that needs their care, and thus to participate in the rapid development. This idea is just so far out of the box of current school systems, it blew me away.
I'm looking forward to getting in depth with this and many other ideas about incorporating emotional and social learning into education. The TEDx GoldenGate ED conference is coming up in just a week, and I believe it will be webcast - stay tuned to http://tedxgoldengateed.org/ for info on that if you're interested. I look forward to this conversation developing!
A reply on Conversation: Lets each record one second every day!
But I think the point is to gain a much longer look at things. Things come and go, always changing, and this process and result remind us of that fact. (Also a nice spin on the phrase "live in the moment")
The seed of this conversation mentions the inspiration getting a 5 hour video by age 80 - that's already approximately two movies, imagine if it was 60x longer! A great video installation, but not practical to watch in one sitting. One second gives you a moment, and these moments add up to a swirl of life. Who knows what lessons will come of the end result, but it should be an interesting view, and the process of making it brings up all sorts of other interesting questions. . .
A reply on Conversation: Reading science fiction for a more critical view of our society?
This is an interesting combination of art and education being discussed. I think Nicholas, you make a great point that "when you practice art, you are thinking," which relates to a workshop I was writing up earlier. The woman who will be running the workshop teaches artistic techniques (I think mostly visual and poetry) to kids, and then gets them to explore the cultural and natural worlds around them, and express their reactions through art.
This gets the kids connected to their environment, both the people around them, and nature (/artificial, I imagine), developing their self-confidence and compassion, hence the inclusion in the conference. What I hadn't thought about was that this also develops their critical thinking as well, and that science fiction does this kind of in reverse(?) - it makes us think about our environment critically, which leads to more awareness.
To the other point, I've been thinking a lot about how the education system (at least here in the US where I am familiar with it) needs a drastic overhaul, but no one is really sure what that should be. There are a lot of ideas out there, and more every day. I think exploring the interconnectedness of subjects that we see as disparate (like art and science) is definitely important, as is addressing different learning and thinking styles.
The "meta-education" mentioned by Simone could be sort of a guide to the world, how to use the knowledge acquired, and (borrowing from sci-fi) imagining what could be important to know for the future. In my remaining space, let me tell you to google the Institute for the Future, and then to plug my TEDx:
https://www.facebook.com/TEDxGoldenGateED
and
http://tedxgoldengateed.org
A reply on Conversation: What kind of power can a film have?
And every now and then there is a movie that leave us speechless and changes us profoundly. I can't say I've had quite the experience that Lindsey had above, but for me, The Fountain left me in that state of stunned(?) thought and I really need to go back and watch it again (luckily not as hard to find as your movies seem to have been).
I'd be honoured if you'd join our small but growing community over on the Facebook ( https://www.facebook.com/TEDxGoldenGateED ), but I will also point to this discussion from our page over there. And I have to quickly plug the conference itself, which you can learn about here: http://tedxgoldengateed.org
We're hoping to build an online community whose discussion will mirror that of the conference itself, while continuing year-round.