Biology student currently studying at McMaster University.
If you agree/disagree with something I've said, or to add an idea of your own, or ask my opinion
16:48 Posted: Jun 2012
Views: 1,181,967 | Comments: 385
19:04 Posted: Mar 2012
Views: 4,420,357 | Comments: 743
22:25 Posted: Jan 2012
Views: 538,085 | Comments: 98
17:21 Posted: Apr 2011
Views: 493,063 | Comments: 309
13:46 Posted: Feb 2011
Views: 1,058,255 | Comments: 207
TEDCred score: +0.20 TEDCred reflects your contribution to the TED community.
A comment on Conversation: Will economics end national wars?
A reply on Conversation: Do you think gay marriage will be universally accepted in the next 10 years?
A reply on Talk: Juan Enriquez: Will our kids be a different species?
A reply on Talk: Juan Enriquez: Will our kids be a different species?
You make a very valid point, as the perceived increase in autism may be an artifact of changing diagnostic practices, and likely is at least to an extent. However, as the authors in one of your papers report, "whether there has been a true increase is not known," thus not ruling out the possibility that there is a trend here. Also, as none of the data you've presented seems to be from any later than 2007 roughly, I would not trust these studies to explain the increase since that time which is the main bulk of time that Mr. Enriquez was looking at and where the largest increase seemed to be.
I agree that a proportion of this increase is probably due to changing practices, however we shall see if this upward pace continues in the years to come and proves to be a verifiable trend. Personally I don't think any part of evolution whatsoever could occur within a decade span let alone complex brain changes. Other than his possibly misguided or better yet overreaching foray into autism/brain downloading, this was an informed talk that is well grounded in current science. Except for maybe changing your own genes, that would be nigh impossible body-wide.
A reply on Talk: Patricia Kuhl: The linguistic genius of babies