Amanda Kunysz Posted over 2 years ago An Eye for an Eye . Do you agree or disagree? to an extent, yes, depending on what crime they have done. Let's say the offender steals a car, as a consequence, yes, the offender should be put into prison and made to repay their victim. Yet on the basis of 'a life for a life' (e.g. the death penalty) I believe that it is wrong to seek revenge by taking someones life.