This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »
Do you use crowd wisdom to think? Be part of creating the first ever crowd sourced TED talk
I'm about to speak at TED 2012 and present the first ever crowd-sourced TED talk :-)
I'm inviting you to be part of this process and create together my presentation.
Before asking for your help, here's my main idea:
Wisdom of Crowds theory exists for many years. The theory states that the collective wisdom of big crowds is smarter than experts as we solve problems or make decisions.
Until recently, the use of the wisdom of crowds was possible primarily for organizations that have invested resources in developing technological solutions that transformed crowd wisdom into products such as Wikipedia.
This means that anyone with enough social network friends can ask questions that will require them to think. The collective wisdom from all the answers is probably the smartest thing to do.
There are already a few people who are using this method. By doing so, they upgrade their ability to think and make decisions significantly.
That's it…
I'm creating my TED talk using crowd wisdom, your wisdom. It will be the first ever crowd sourced TED talk.
I hope that you'll join me in this journey and take part of this process.
I'm looking for exceptional individuals (not organizations) who are using their own social network profile in order to get crowd wisdom in a way that improves their personal or professional lives significantly.
I'll share their stories in my TED talk :-)
Here are a few areas of interest – musicians, educators, designers, spiritual leaders, marketing experts, people looking for relationships etc.
In addition, if you have interesting stories or ideas that might add value to this topic, I'll be happy if you share them with me.
You can join my journey and get more information at my blog http://liorz.co.il/blog
Looking forward to read your insights.
Thank you.
Lior
Closing Statement from Lior Zoref
Thank you for the amazing insights and feedback.
You can read the text of my talk here - http://www.ted.com/conversations/8326/the_first_ever_crowd_sourced_t.html
Thank you so much.
Lior














Robert Winner 50+
Zared Schwartz
Lior Zoref 50+
Thank you for your feedback and insights.
I come from Israel. Last summer a huge movement started by the crowd asking for social justice. It was well organized and its impact is big.
I'm not an expert in civil protests and it's an interesting question to see what is the role of crowd wisdom in these events.
Lior
Pam Drake
Then, a news article appeared about her sons' situation (her youngest is disabled, and the older one is in school full time). http://www.dailybreeze.com/news/ci_19617094
Now we are starting fundraising to benefit her sons. I put the word out, and others have passed it on. The idea of using social media came from reading about your project. I'm hoping that it works well.
Lior Zoref 50+
Pam Drake
manuel ruiz-echarri
Robert Winner 50+
Zared Schwartz
Lior Zoref 50+
Thanks,
Lior
Zared Schwartz
Lior Zoref 50+
Crowds are not only right the same as experts make mistakes.
Thanks for the insight.
Zared Schwartz
http://www.ted.com/conversations/8101/let_us_change_the_world_by_usi.html
Lior Zoref 50+
Lior
Si Xie 10+
I am also amazed by how the collaboration of people, ideas, resource that make the world closer and more intellectual. Maybe you can put something like multicultural environment and people with diverse background may have some unique contribution to others. The interdependent relationship can enrich the content and areas of crowd wisdom. Like different theory or tradition in different culture or countries, etc. From the benefits to individuals, then to the community.
Lior Zoref 50+
This is an interesting idea.
I'm asking a question at the beginning of my talk in which everyone can use their smart phones and answer.
Maybe I should add something which relates to your idea.
Thank you!
Lior
Si Xie 10+
Zared Schwartz
Marsellla Charron
www.ideaconnection.com
Lior Zoref 50+
Thanks for sharing this web-site. It looks very impressive.
But I am more interested in crowdsourcing for personal use. People who are using social networks to think together with others.
Thank you.
Lior
Marsellla Charron
http://blog.ted.com/2011/10/17/learning-from-a-barefoot-movement-bunker-roy-on-ted-com/
The other is from a TED conversation I was reading about the topic Corporate Rebels. One person, Lois Kelly had posted an interesting presentation on what makes a corporate rebel. It is a different topic but I thought it did relate since these 'rebels' tend to act based on wanting their company to succeed rather then for self branding.
http://www.slideshare.net/Foghound/corporate-rebel-ebook
Both these these topics were about using 'non-leaders' expertise or natural talents to create innovate change. Is it possible to have a crowd wisdom consisting of experts? I don't know if you believe crowd wisdom must incorporate every single voice but it certainly seems that people weed themselves out by being lackadaisical. Meaning, not everyone cares to put the effort in to be apart of a movement or change.
Hope it helps and good luck with your talk. Enjoy!
Mark Monroe
- How do you know whether the decision of the crowd is wise or stupid?
- What happens when the crowd’s choice goes against science (as in evolution)?
- What do you do when a crowd decides that Jews are evil and need to be destroyed?
- Who decides what the crowd can decide on in the first place? Can a crowd say whether or not slavery is wise, or is that simply off the table? But who says it is off the table, an expert I assume.
A crowd is wise only after an expert has decided that the crowd did a wise thing. You ignore all the times when the crowd does the stupid thing at your own peril.
Crowd wisdom appears to me to be another argument for collectivism. I thought Ayn Rand killed that bug a long time ago.
Poll Source:
http://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20100210/percentage-of-overweight-obese-americans-swells
Lior Zoref 50+
Thank you for your feedback.
You are right, crowds could be wrong, just the same as experts can (and are) sometimes wrong.
But you gave me food for thought.
Thank you,
Lior
heaven ian
I do believe nothing happens by accident.
Before I came into this conversation, i am thinking of posting a question in Facebook, to solicit reactions from social friends. Now I am starting to understand about "crowd wisdom".
For the meantime, i have bookmarked your blog and will share info with you hoping it can help in your talk.
To begin with, let me share to you this...
Proverbs 9:10..."The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom, and knowledge of the Holy One is understanding.
The Bible NIV
God bless you with wisdom.
rey del rosario (aka heavenian)
David Hamilton 50+
In case you haven't seen it.
http://www.ted.com/talks/luis_von_ahn_massive_scale_online_collaboration.html
Morry Patoka
My experience with crowd wisdom is very practical. For years we've used a group collaborative system to generate insights, ideas and strategies that actually get implemented, mostly because of the crowd dynamics that created the ideas in the first place. Bringing together a group in person, the right group, is not much different than what's needed to make online crowd wisdom work well. Some of the comments in this conversation bring up similar points, but here are a few of the basics that we've discovered over thousands of hours facilitating insight, ideation and strategy sessions.
You need some experts, but not too many or they will act as blinders to the crowd, keeping the conversation too narrow or dismissing ideas that are too far out there.
People tend to be linear in their thinking so you have to introduce instigators that break them out of their traditional thinking patterns. Metaphors, pictures, music, creativity exercises get our brains to another place quickly. Once we're there it's much easier to discover new things we would have otherwise missed, or connect dots that would have never made sense until we opened our minds.
Focus is critical to outcomes. Focus doesn't mean preventing exploration. On the contrary, it helps groups to see opportunities more clearly. One of the jobs of a facilitator in a crowd is to take the nuggets, hold them back up to the crowd and say, "hey, look at this. Can this help us get to an answer we can use?"
If you'd like more detailed explanation I have a number of articles on my blog site that can help. You can get the link from my profile if you're interested. I don't want to come across as promoting. From your responses to comments I see that you've already tapped into some of the great books on the subject.
Good luck on your Ted talk. I'm looking forward to it.
Lior Zoref 50+
Thank you so much for your insights.
I'd love to take a look at your blog.
Lior
Tiago Landman
Lior Zoref 50+
I recommend that you'll real about Wisdom of Crowds theory here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wisdom_of_Crowds
It is true that stupidity can also result from crowds but in many times, crowd wisdom is an amazing outcome of many people thinking together.
Lior
Artis Zeigurs
Thomas Brucia
simon roger
Lior Zoref 50+
Artis Zeigurs
For example a child with rare desease. crowd wisdom will say - find an expert or i know one or give some aspirin in double dose and see where it goes, i reciently did so! the last advice if you are lucky will only waste time,
Lior Zoref 50+
Thanks for the idea.
Lior
Artis Zeigurs
Lior Zoref 50+
How does this relate to crowd wisdom?...
Lior
William Robson
http://storify.com/MOMBCOMICS/twittercomic-2011
Home to twitters 1st comic
Shameless self plug on my "Storifies". I did the Twitter town hall Storify while the town hall was happening and was able to publish it the same miniute it was done. It used 20 different Twitter users with responses from the Mayor Included.
http://storify.com/wrobson
It is my belief that when we all collaborate we change the desire for creating a strict profit driven model for consuming. In a highly controlled market such as education or textbooks the desire to profit reduces the access to the product. However this is highly counter productive to creating a strong educated society. education costs should be low, but by design they are not. Websites like the www.Khanacademy.com are trying to change this. If our governments and educational institutions worked together they could create a library of information for everyone to use at an extremely low cost. Publishers would just have to find something different to publish!
Good luck on the talk!
Erin Klein
Erin Klein
Predrag Bokšić
Mary M. 100+
Yours is a very interesting project Lior, love this thread of conversation.
Here's a quote for you: "None of us is as smart as all of us." (Eric Schmidt)
Hope my contribution though small, helps you in some way.
Lior Zoref 50+
I totally agree. It's too bad that educators are not the first to understand the power of sharing and crowd wisdom.
Thank you for your insight and great quote.
Lior
Arjan Neumann
Student - Teacher - Market expert
Simple logica tells me that many teachers never visit a business or company so they just only chew the letters in the books so the students eat them easy.! It should be able to sign up for teaching when a company can affort to work with 1 employee less for a certain time. Or someone who is goin to retire or maybe even have a depression. This can be good therapy too i think. Students should get more access to to knowledge and be able to discuss around the table with the teacher and market expert.
If companies decide to make time for employees to help out with teaching they should get credits that can be used for advertising job vacancies : for example students who pass get tour and/or additional information.
It's important that the reward is unfair high so the market will wake up and challenge. May the best win! Students who can't find a job can join too! People who got sick can join too! There should be a "flying army" of people around every class/school. Meshed up international perhaps or set up non-profit projects in holidays/weekends. To reach the people who would never go to study.
Schools with high scores help the schools who do less good. This should be monitored and controlled and documented here is the science behind teaching. An army of students of any sector that can help joins. And will go step by step class by class school by school. The more work u do the less u pay for ur education, if pay more u can contact anyone who then will be rewarded. like this even the worst students are important, and they will get boosted.
Get people to hunt just like in nature, addept to new situations, travel, explore, communicate, work together, protecting, playing, invest, harvest, observe, hunt to find weakness, love to find the good. All connected to the three elements given earlier : Student : Teacher : Market expert.
The system should work like tax but then the tax are working hours.
Artis Zeigurs
Arnab Majumdar
Crowdsourcing as a concept is the wave of the future in development work. ICT4D, or Information and Communication Technologies for Development, is already taking off in Africa. Developers have already produced applications that enable cheap, Java-based mobile phone users in major cities to upload and share current gas prices, for example, farmers to share health concerns and agricultural yields to better inform policy both from a governmental and NGO perspective, and the organisation I'm based at, the Uganda Red Cross, is designing a mobile phone survey with our donors to improve the incentive structure underpinning blood colleciton. These are just some of the solutions that are taking off, very much made possible by the exponential rise of mobile phone technology and the expanded reach it has provided.
Most development workers will tell you that one of the problems with development organisations in the South is fragmentation; there are way too many organisations performing similar functions, with limited information sharing and collaboration between them, one of the reasons why such projects are slow to begin, difficult to implement, and often unsustainable over the long-term. For this reason, I wonder whether the wisdom of crowds theory is relevant not only in social networks, but also as an ideal to pursue within the professional sphere. Even going part of the way sometimes makes a huge impact. My home-based NGO, Pepal, for example, brings together the corporate sector, domestic NGOs, and academic participants to work on development projects together. As such, there is a huge skillset transfer as the partnerships flourish, and as the project takes off each actor gains input all the way down to their teams. The end result is a more refined project with the power of multiple actors.
Good luck with the presentation!
Kerri Bodie
For decades, I have seen on tv, starving infants in 3rd world countries, shriveling up like raisins in their mother's arms, both crying to a world that appears to ignore them. The plight of my poverty stricken sisters around the world haunts me, knowing every day they are enduring a mother's worst nightmare.
As I searched for answers, to my surprise & disgust, I discovered that food scarcity is actually artificial – a deliberate political maneuver & nothing more.
Every human being should have the inalienable right to a full stomach & a full brain, in my opinion.
I also learned that the technology I used for my research, requires specific minerals that are mined from many poverty stricken areas of the world by corporations that often use child slave labor to keep costs low & profits high. This is a massive human rights tragedy, and it is impossible to ignore the fact that the world's rabid demand for new technology is destroying the planet.
I feel that if we have access to all this technology because of the blood, sweat & tears extorted from corporate slave labor, we have the moral obligation to use this technology to give these people, & our planet, a voice.
The phenomenon of the internet and social networking media are two powerful tools, that if used effectively, through a cooperative effort like a “Crowd Sourced TED Talk”, we could circumvent corrupt corporate politics & quickly find simple, wise solutions.
I feel no one is actually free unless we are all free - there are many more human beings on this planet who want peace, than who want war. We are clever - we can do this.
I would consider it an honor Lior, to be a part of your “Crowd Sourced TED Talk” centered around bringing food and education to all, and leaving a much needed viable future for our planet & the entire human race.
Lior Zoref 50+
Thank you for raising this important issue.
I ask myself (and others), how crowd wisdom can help solve the burning issues of the 3rd world. I wish leaders were using crowd wisdom more... But there must be other ideas.
If anyone knows of any example of this happening, please let me know.
Thanks for the complements :-)
Lior
Artis Zeigurs