TED Conversations

Chris Scott

This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »

What can we do about the constant rise of depression and suicide in young adults?

I am seventeen years of age and have recently come out of a large stage of my life where I dealt with a lot of depression. I have dealt with and still deal with people in high school (and even middle school in some cases) that deal with depression every single day and never have anyone that they talk to about their problems.

I have known people that have committed suicide from the weight of depression upon their shoulders throughout their lives, and have heard about these cases all over the world. I, myself, have been driven to the point where I thought that the only way out of my depression was by suicide because there was nothing to help me.

I want to know your opinions and ideas on the subject of depression and suicide in young adults today and what we can do to prevent these problems in the future. Thanks for listening!

+11
Share:

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.

  • thumb
    Oct 29 2011: Thank you Chris for initiating this.
    Today I learned that those experiencing sea sickness often feel slightly depressed before becoming actually sick and might even feel suicidal. (I heard it on a Danish science program on Norvegian television.) Sea sickness is the result of conflicting sensory information (from balance organs opposed to eyes) that creates a chaos. This internal chaos is speculated to be interpreted by our bodies as having been poisoned and results in vomiting.
    I immediately thought of land based depressive and suicidal states. I think that the internal conflict due to unusual awareness of the discrepancies between our heart and our world results in a similar chaos. Our bodies rightfully think that secluded rest is needed for the brain to resolve matters. Often this works sufficiently to go on living, but sometimes the ability to understand extreme contradictions of viewpoints leaves no point of reference.
    The sea sick feels better when steering the ship. How do we accomplish the feeling of steering our own ships in sometimes dangerous waters? I believe our heart is our compass.
    • Oct 30 2011: The constant reaching for a fixed point of reference in our experience is also part of the problem. When we feel troubled with something, be it motion sickness or emotion sickness, it's not because of the experience itself but because of our interpretation and insistence for it to be different than it actually is.

      I agree that our heart is our compass. Instead of looking for the feeling of steering our own ships, or some other feeling that isn't there, a nice and worthwhile exercise is to simply look at feelings that are already there and let go of our interpretations for a second. Alongside those feelings and any other experience at that moment, will be thoughts about the experience. Those are the interpretations. Instead of taking those at face value, we can watch those thoughts come and go as just another part of that experience, without investing anything in them.

      If we actually try this from time to time, we can see that those experiences can't actually touch us. Even if at first you're still inclined to get caught in a gut wrenching spiral, that too is only part of the experience, which comes, maybe sticks around for a while, and then goes if there's no more investment in it.
      • thumb
        Oct 30 2011: Well said Mark,
        I agree that our interpretations, expectations, reaching for a fixed point of reference, and investment in a certain outcome often color our experiences. Observing the thoughts come and go, and experiencing the "flow" of thoughts, rather than focusing on a certain thought, can sometimes allow us to move through thoughts and feelings that we prefer not to have. This practice works well for many people to interupt the depression "spiral".

        With that said, we also need to be aware of clinical depression, which may be more difficult to deal with, and may need professional intervention.
        • Oct 30 2011: Certainly sometimes professional help is needed, for addressing specific issues. But specific issues of one sort or another will always be there. Taking a slightly longer view, we'd obviously want to be less susceptible to issues, if we could. And what I'm saying is, we can.

          We are susceptible to issues because we interpret them as being personal. That belief is what causes us to constantly push and pull at whatever comes up, not realizing that we can never change the fact that it has already come up. We can't stop pushing and pulling until we stop believing that all the ups and downs of life are a personal affair. How this happens can be directly seen in one's own experience, and only when this is actually seen for what it is, can we decide to take it for what it actually is. Which is, not personal.
      • thumb
        Oct 30 2011: To search for a point of reference might be the only way for people with unusually developed sense of balance. They are exceptionally well equipped to sense the imbalances in life and therefore prone to develop depressions as a means to help resolve the contradictory feelings of for example a family divorce or other devastating human discrepancies.
        Depressions are like fever is to an infection and should be left to take its course in rest and solitude with help and support from persons close. If the depression has not diminished after some weeks some expert guidance is probably needed. Guided by someone who does not see the depression itself as the original sickness but as part of the cure.
        A feeling of relative balance can be found when we calibrate our major thoughts and feelings to our heart. The heart has been shown to posess neurons like in our brain and there are two-way communications between heart and brain.
        I believe in watching out for thoughts and feelings that are extrapolations from the compass of our heart. They are our points of reference, forever changing as we go.
        • Oct 30 2011: It makes sense to distinguish between the occurance of an infection, and the occurance of a fever as an immunological response to that infection. But I don't see in what sense you are suggesting that depression exists as phenomenally distinct from feelings. Also neurons exist throughout the entire body. It's called the nervous system. When hypothesizing, since analysis of reality is not the same as reality itself, there's the constant risk of the analysis getting convoluted with fantasy.

          I agree that when in the midst of overwhelming turmoil, that might not be the best time to learn to let go of the need of a fixed reference point, because this requires a trust which is gained incrementally. But the problem is, when we do find something to hold on to, we think we're fine. Until inevitably the next turmoil comes along and we loose our footing once again. This is perfectly predictable, and yet we are content to let it surprise us over and over, and then we blame it on the lack of footing.

          But when this pattern becomes apparent, there's another option to choose from. And that is to stop convincing ourselves time after time that whatever footing we may find, is there to stay. We already know it isn't, whether we'd care to face it or not. And the beauty of it is, those ups and downs are exactly why life can exist at all :). If we can see and appreciate this for what it is, without taking it personally each and every time we're riding the down slope, things will suddenly look whole a lot different.
      • thumb
        Oct 31 2011: Thank you Mark Meijer for taking notice that I was very unclear about what I meant by heart and brain interactions. Here is the research I am leaning heavily on scientifically in that aspect: http://www.heartmath.org/research/science-of-the-heart/head-heart-interactions.html.
        I am at a loss to where I found the interesting information with speculations as to why humans through evolution have been equipped with the ability for being depressed. I believe it to be very probable that depression has benign functions.
        Such as helping humans in dire emotional circumstances by inducing them to rest in solitude and for example either emptying their minds of thought and feeling or rethinking difficulties again and again. These states of mind maybe makes it easier for the unconscious to regroup and find a way to positively consolidate these new learnings into the system. If the depression can take its course you ultimately might emerge stronger.
        I agree that we need the ups and downs to evolve beautifully. Each personal setback is a sign for us to try to overcome it in a way as to learn and grow. We can beautifully never predict what comes to us. And we can never know how we will evolve. We are all children of sorts. Learning gets easier when we acknowledge that comforting fact.
        The ability to acknowledge our heart as our compass gives a point of direction that can be trusted whatever strange turns of directions life takes you in order to grow. Small obstacles might be overcome by ignoring them but some have to be mastered in order to be able to move forward.
      • thumb
        Oct 31 2011: I wonder if there exists any gathered data about what formerly suicidals consider to be the most important factors that made them want to live. I have only heard one clear account. It was from a boy who unsuccessfully went through several therapies. What made the last theraphy work was that the therapist showed him genuine interest.
        Do you need to feel that at least some person genuinly cares about who you are? To feel that you are neither completely alone nor forced to comply wholly to others in order to find company. Maybe you can then find the courage to travel some distances alone. And feel confident that you will find others to accompany you on part of your ways, even if seemingly unchartered.
        We suffer when alone and we suffer when in too restraining company.
        How to navigate your own personal route while keeping in contact with those you love is often tricky.
        You can believe that storms and narrow gaps are given as opportunities to become a better navigator. Nobody knows where they are going and that is beautiful. Take the time to read the compass when you suspect that you are lost. Find your bearing. Chris, it is there to find.
    • thumb
      Oct 31 2011: The heart is our compass, and the only.

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.