This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »
LIVE CHAT With Adam Ostrow: What should happen to your digital identity after you die?
The average social media user will create hundreds of thousands of pieces of content in their lifetime. Already, this is changing the way we remember our loved ones and creating a legacy that is much different than that of any previous generation.
At the same time, technology's ability to understand vast amounts of data is expanding exponentially, and in the long run, enabling the possibility of leveraging our social media footprint to create a version of us that can live on long after we're gone.
What do you want to have happen to your digital identity after you die? Would you give an AI permission to post content and interact online after your death? Why or why not?
ADMIN UPDATE: This LIVE CHAT will open on August 9, 2011 at 2PM EST/ 5PM PST.
Closing Statement from Adam Ostrow
A few thoughts in closing:
(1) There's a large interest in people assigning an executor for their digital assets after they die. A number of startups already serve this need. One issue with this though -- what happens when the services noted in the will change, close, get acquired, etc? That will create similar issues to the ambiguous wills of today.
(2) Lots of questions about whether or not the complete recreation of ones self, which I forecast towards the end of my talk, could make it more challenging to find closure. Outside of that, however, it at the very least seems like an intriguing opportunity for future generations to get to know their ancestors.
(3) In thinking about this topic, it's important to remember that the social media tools of today are incredibly primitive compared to what we'll be using in the future. The type of data we'll be capturing 5, 10 or 50 years from now is what's needed to make an AI-powered scenario realistic.
(4) Thanks to those that shared their personal stories of already dealing with these issues. It's a huge help in thinking about the topic going forward.














Kenny Cheung
Ronel Kelmen
Katharine Steele
But, a digital will could be a great exercise for HS seniors - as morbid as it sounds to someone so young, philosophically, it might in turn give them a reality check and help them focus on goals for their lives after HS.
Amy Nelson
Jerry Sullivan
Joanna Pike
Stephen Fox
Thank you and best wishes
Adam Ostrow 100+
Pedro Nogueira
Stephen Fox
Zane Thorn
Stephen Fox
Krishnam Raju
Every web service should ask a set of questions which will decide which information can be passed on to whom when the user dies.
The set of questions vary depending upon the kind of web service like Facebook will have a different set of questions when compared to Gmail and Twitter.
I think its the time for every web service to initiate this process. I would love to see this happening.
Joanna Pike
If the site you use makes it as easy as Intersect so that you determine with every 'story' or 'post' who can see it with one click - there shouldn't be an issue with people you don't want accessing your information after your death.
Within your account, you should be able, as suggested by one comment here earlier, to nominate a virtual 'executor' of your details. There could be a form that goes with this outlining specific requests. It would be as responsible as making a will. Just digitally.
Are there any downsides to this?
Adam Ostrow 100+
Joanna Pike
John Armstrong
Adam Ostrow 100+
Kenny Cheung
John Armstrong
Anne Shirako
Mark Krynsky
This is such a new area that will require a rethinking in many areas in the future. I believe people should have their digital legacy wishes outlined in their wills. I feel that a digital legacy will provide so much more for future generations to learn about their family and heritage. All I have to remember my grandparents are a few photos and stories told by my parents. I'd love to be able to browse and search their digital legacies to learn more about them.
I can also see an opportunity for changes in businesses such as funeral homes and cemeteries. The digital legacies could be used for family members to help share a life at a memorial and cemeteries could also offer kiosks that provide the digital legacy for people to view. I see many changes and innovations that will result around this area in the future.
Adam Ostrow 100+
Nana Brew-Hammond
Karin Høgh
Adam Ostrow 100+
Tarun Teja Gotimukala
Leave the profile the way it is, default is the best in this case, at least from my point of view!
Adam Ostrow 100+
Tobias Heemskerk 20+
Zane Thorn
Adam Ostrow 100+
Tobias Heemskerk 20+
Ronel Kelmen
Adam Ostrow 100+
Zane Thorn
Tarun Teja Gotimukala
Martha Fish
Being remembered, and being remembered well is important to some people. After all the Stuff we do in this life, it is the relationships we create with other people that will matter the most.I am into genealogy research. Being able to research on the internet you turn up all sorts of traces nowadays for people who have lived part of their lives through the internet. I appreciate that there is an archive-of sorts, of this electronic world, but don't count on that. Write your life's story if you want your great grand children to know about you. You don't want to be - Page Not Found. Publish or Perish, or publish And perish.
I believe that the part of us that is living this life in this body endures after the death of the body. Memorials and tributes for the dead are mostly for the grieving of the living. I don't know that re-opening a facebook page is my kind of memorial ( there are other places for that), but that was interesting. My father was in the cemetery business. He wanted to implant something into the headstone (like they have photographs now) that would play a video of the person's life, even written and orchestrated by the deceased themselves. That is certainly possible now. If our spirit lives on then we can take comfort in not being so attached to our digital identities maybe.
I want to live my life now without regrets. Life is a work in progress. I don't doubt that there will be loose ends no matter when I go. Maybe one of the duties of an executor would be to tie up the loose ends in the electronic world, too. Sigh
Zane Thorn
Adam Ostrow 100+
muzammil baig
Lana Montalban
Adam Ostrow 100+
R Kyle Williams
Adam Ostrow 100+
Katharine Steele
They then used his Facebook account to slander and libel me online and blocked me as well as many of our mutual friends from his account, so I couldn't see what they were posting about me - using HIS account. Due to FB's inherent lack of customer service and response, my only option was to request to memorialize his account, which effectively locked it so they couldn't abuse it. However, now all of his friends they defriended cannot view his wall and post memories to share with so many others that are still on his friends list that love him. Because of the blocking, on both sides for their personal accounts, I can't see what they may be posting more about me on his fan page I created for him.
As he was a creative and talented comedian, actor and filmmaker, now something that could have been used to carry on his legacy, has been misused and abused and used as a weapon. The only thing I didn't give them access to was his blog and like page (thankfully), which I still manage and post things that I find or other friends share with me. I sincerely doubt he ever would have approved of this and it is painful to think about, but I continue on trying to preserve and share the legacy of his creative genius and beautiful sweet soul.
Adam Ostrow 100+
Zane Thorn
Katharine Steele
Katharine Steele
Pedro Nogueira
Joanna Pike
Katharine Steele
...and funny thing is, I haven't asked for a nickel. I might be able to understand if this was about money, but I don't want a cent. Just want him to be remembered the way he would have wanted to be.
Pedro Nogueira
Some people...you just can't understand. Just can't...understand. What can we think?!
Raymond Andrews
Either way, I suppose someone would be able to set up such an AI if there was enough content from the deceased that it could learn from. Almost a creepy thought.
Adam Ostrow 100+
Pedro Nogueira
I don't really know. I don't like the idea of thousands of people that i've never known in my life, giving their laments. And i say this because, although internet is a social utility, i don't have a real bond with those people. For those who really loved me in life, i think that they'll want their time alone not being bothered.
But, on the other hand, most people don't do things on bad purpose. I don't blame them on making people live through internet. It's nice in its way. I understand.
What i make in life and waht i do in life is what my loved ones will retain of me. That is what counts. I won't be here to see the rest. Can i let my personality flow through the internet?
I don't know.
I'm 24.
Do i want a life made by memories and thoughts of others?
Or do i want peace?
I think it's a real good topic and i wrote this in a rush but...yeah, i'll live on and i'll see what pops in my head.
Fatemeh Khatibloo
I'm loathe to think that the lovely and wonderful things a friend may have written on my Wall, or the photos a family member posts on Flickr are ephemeral -- that they will be eradicated upon deactivation of that person's account. On the other hand, it's important to provide users a choice about whether they want to be exposed to photos and memories of a person they're grieving.
As to the question of AI-created interactions post-mortem, I frankly don't think we're ready for that, psychologically. Mourning is a critical part of the human condition, and there have been SO many changes to how we undertake that process already. I don't think we've adapted fully, and the very notion that some insentient, digital version of my father could continue to interact with me feels like it would be horribly detrimental to my ability to grieve.
Adam Ostrow 100+
One application I think is interesting, however, is down the line being able to "meet" your great grandparents, or other relatives you never knew when they were alive. That's one of the things that's so radically different about the generations to follow -- they will know so much more about their ancestors than we do today.
Joanna Pike
Autumn Godwin
James Puckett
Joanna Pike
Corvida Raven 100+
I think it would be fun to have an AI post a blog, picture, or video of my choosing for every birthday I have after my death. I'd prerecord them with a guess as to what I think I would've done that past year and what I hope to do in the next. I wouldn't go beyond this because I don't think it's necessary. I don't necessarily want to give my family and friends artificial memories of me. I want them to remember what they already have.
Sounds cruel and heartbreaking on some level, but I think it could be a way for some of my friends and family to find peace, and for me to still show them love.
Adam Ostrow 100+
Corvida Raven 100+
Though death affects everyone differently.
Zane Thorn
Patricia Guerra
Think about.
What happens if anybody's memories would not remain after we die ? Your existence would be somehow diminished or maybe not even be known.
Why not leave behind pictures of great moments of laughter and joy ? Why would I want to be remembered by the way that I die ? Instead, isn't much better, and maybe wiser to be remembered by what I have lived for and all the things that I've done ??
This world is indeed a temporary endeavor, but it is a necessary path, otherwise we would not be here. And the experiences are temporary but your legacy and memories are forever.
Adam Ostrow 100+
Zane Thorn
Joanna Pike
muzammil baig
Adam Ostrow 100+
Zane Thorn
Autumn Godwin
Zane Thorn
Adam Ostrow 100+
What's your company?
Zane Thorn
We allow people to upload media and tell their story with a combination of text, video, audio and images. We also allow people to "tell the story in their own words" by using a webcam. Everything is displayed on a timeline of that person's life. Each story can have privacy settings enabled that allow the user to choose who can see each story, so the more personal ones can be shared only with close family. You may also elect a person to administer your account after you die.
Joanna Pike
Zane Thorn