Peter Andersen

Volunteer, The Scout Association

This conversation is closed.

Has Andrew Bird done a good job with his music, or is technology the only thing carrying him?

If you read the comments on this video, many of them is about Andrew Bird being lazy and some even says unproffesional.
So this confuses me a little, what is, a brilliant musician or a lazy technician?
3 things to think about:
- Is it unproffesional to work 5 months on 1 song, or does it show patience and passion?
- Do the music industry allow enough musician like Andrew Bird to be heard, so people can get used to this kind of music and what can be done if this isn't the case?
- Has the technology in music damaged or helped, and what are the pros and cons of using technology?

  • thumb
    Feb 27 2011: I don't believe technology is carrying Andrew. After all, he is controlling the technology throughout his performances, is he not? In my perception, that takes another kind of talent, in addition to the voice and instruments he's playing. Those who say he is lazy and unprofessional, may be criticizing, based on their own judgemental filters? Who cares if he works 5 months on a song? Why would anyone judge a person for going at his/her own pace?Technology is probably here to stay, so why not use it in as many creative ways as possible? As I stated in my comment on the site, I am intrigued by his willingness to express some of the underlying influences, like scientific theories, physical and emotional challenges.
  • thumb
    Feb 22 2011: That is an interesting question. I have to admit the first time I heard that TED actually had musicians perform I wondered when Andrew Bird was going to do a performance, and I am surprised it took so long. I have actually criticized Bird's work before for unoriginality but it is because I feel he reuses themes between albums a little much, not because I think he lacks talent. His style of playing is actually extremely difficult. Were he playing over pre-recorded loops then I would be more inclined to agree that technology was limiting him, but actively laying on top of yourself is no easy feat.
  • thumb
    Mar 3 2011: It is only very funny.but it isnot a real music.I regret to say I appreciate his freedom,but I don't learn to appreciate those of his pleasures that are not realily available in my music field.