This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »
Probiotics, like yogurt, are known to support healthy gut microbes. How could we apply this idea support a healthy house, subway, or office?
Live TED Conversation: Join TED Fellow Jessica Green
Jessica is the Director of the Biology and Built Environment (BioBE) Center. Our goal is to optimize the design and operation of buildings to promote both human health and environmental sustainability.
*UPDATE* Jessica will be answering questions LIVE from 1:30PM - 3PM EDT, June 10th, 2011. This conversation will remain open until 6:30PM EDT, June 10th, 2011.
Closing Statement from Jessica Green
Thanks to everyone for sharing your thoughts. I will take this conversation with me as we continue to explore issues surrounding biology and the built environment.














Troels Fredberg
Jessica Green 200+
I have also seen literature suggesting that building design influences human health (e.g. see Healing Spaces by E. Sternberg). One component of our work that I am enthusiastic about is exploring how natural light and natural ventilation, both of which are believe to have positive health effects (for reasons that are not 100% understood), influence microbes indoors.
Simon Waters
Loss of alcohol ;)
Simon Waters
Maxime Touzel
Jessica Green 200+
Sadee Whip
I believe probiotics are the wave of the future. Seriously. Such an exciting field you are in!!
Thank you for any help and all the best!
Katherine Baluta
I'm asking because I was considering one of the threads about microclimates, that is, a building or block of buildings that house like-minded people and businesses. I'd assume that different parts of the country would sustain different kinds of businesses because of local economies (for example, a building in Arizona would necessarily house a different sort of "green build" business and different agriculturalists than one in Washington). The microclimate of probiotics happens to be internal; do different populations support slightly different ones? If we manufacture probiotics, are they "simple" enough to bypass the need for specific (probably name branded) strains and a homogeneous culture? I'm sorry if these are obvious questions, I was just thinking about how various yeast cultures can lead to different tastes in cooking.
Jessica Green 200+
For example, I just read a study on spit (by Mark Stoneking and colleagues) that shows there is great variation in saliva microbial diversity among individuals, but that your neighbor’s spit is just as likely to be similar to yours as the spit of someone on the other side of the globe. So, there is little geographic signal in saliva microbial diversity.
If I understand your points correctly, I believe you are interested in the role of nature versus nurture (or genes versus environment) in shaping microbial community composition in and on the human body. Scientists are using twins to answer these types of questions. To date, twin studies suggest that host genetic factors and environmental exposures are both important drivers of gut microbial community composition.
You are wondering if one type of building probiotic would work for everyone. In other words, one suite of indoor microbes could be healthy (or commensal) to some individuals, and unhealthy for others. For this reason, it might be sensible to tailor the building microbes to match the genotype/phenotype/environment/lifestyle of the people that are occupying those spaces.
I really appreciate your thoughts and will consider this more.
Troels Fredberg
* House ventilation -blowing air through water with microbes (see compost tea).
* Household products with probiotics (apple cider vinegar?).
* Creating small biotopes indoors with microbial cultures on natural elements.
* Living buildings (using dirt as building material).
Jessica Green 200+
We think about lot about ventilation at the BioBE Center. Can you explain a bit more your ideas of blowing air through water with microbes?
I'm inspired by your biotope idea, I have not seen this language used for microbes in the built environment.
I am also very interested in sampling from buildings that have biological components as building materials, to see how this influences, for example, the airborne microbiota.
With regards to your probiotic/household product idea .... I recently read a paper by Noah Fierer and his colleagues that shows how we leave our microbial "fingerprints" on surfaces. For example, they showed that you can link a computer keyboard to the person who it belongs to based on the microbial communities on their fingertips. I wonder if swabbing indoor surfaces with any microbial community (e.g. the apple cide vinegar) would leave a similar signature? Or, if over time the microbes would decrease in their abundance.
Troels Fredberg
I got to think of it as I'm currently experimenting with compost tea for my garden. Compost tea is made by steeping compost or worm castings in a bucked with an air hose filled with water and some liquid molasses and often other ingredients as liquid seaweed extract. It's used as a foliar spray -against pests and bugs and for nutrient absorption through the stomata in the leaves. It's also used to "feed" soil with beneficial bacteria and fungi to break down organic matter and minerals, and to work in symbiosis with the rootweb.
The idea would be to implement a waterbased culture of microorganisms to the ventilation system, so that all the air would have to go through the water.
Louvonnie T
Antibiotics unfortantely though wipe out both good and bad bacteria, then add in other toxins and products that disrupt the system as well....thereby weakening the immune system over time and creating dysbiosis in the gut. Allopathic medicine does not routinely recommend the use of probiotics after a round of antibiotics to re-establish the good bacteria in the gut however. If dysbiosis is present, it cannot function to its true potential, as it was designed to do.
I am just not aware that inhaling probiotics would result in the intended action. However, I do like the natural water filter idea. I like many of the ideas here. But the only absorption I am aware of with probiotics is that of ingestion. Does anyone know otherwise??
I like the central cooling idea though too....and if the benefit lies not in the utilization of the bacteria in the body specifically, but for the purpose of challenging the bad bacteria in a particular enviornment, this may be do-able. But how would you create it to be self-sustaining, could you do that, to eliminate costs?? Would it be economically feasible, and of a great benefit? I could see hospitals benefitting from such technology, as nosocomial infection is a huge problem there.
Barbara Hawkins-Scott
Emiliano Zapata
Jessica Green 200+
You comment about areas with poor sanitation reminds me of work I hope to do in the developing world, where the frequency of pathogens (especially respiratory pathogens) is often higher, and where low-cost control strategies (such as natural ventilation) are especially important. I am interested in quantifying how affordable architectural design practices can be used to significantly reduce the spread of infectious diseases in resource-limited settings. Do you have any suggestions for me about how I might have the biggest impact in this area?
Lindsay Newland Bowker 50+
But you have to get his attention firts says the monk.
And so it is with yiur beutaiful plan. People say theu sharethese values but their hearts and minds arent ther ein action..in will..in determination.
Can you bring your talk back as open ended so we can explore that more????
Thank you again for your beautiful vision. I hold it with you.
Louvonnie T
I wonder if we couldn't use probiotics in place of perservatives? Take the toxic, less beneficial things out of the food supply of which people do react to or have a much higher probability of reacting to, and use probiotics instead? Not only will it preserve the food hopefully, but the people will be ingesting health instead of other things not specifically geared towards health.
Hilal Eren
Anrahyah Arstad
Jessica Green 200+
Here is another thought. It is possible that by constantly disinfecting surfaces, we are removing "healthy" microbes that would otherwise compete with potential pathogens.
Stephanie Geuns-Meyer
Jessica Green 200+
I published a paper titled "Relationship between cystic fibrosis respiratory tract bacterial communities and age, genotype, antibiotics and Pseudomonas aeruginosa" you might find interesting (which can be downloaded here http://biology.uoregon.edu/people/green/publications.html). In this study, we explore how microbes colonize the lungs of people with cystic fibrosis. When we wrote the paper, the current thinking was that healthy human lungs are sterile. But my guess is that this will change, and we may find that healthy lungs are in fact not sterile.
Some of what we inhale also gets into our gut. Do you have anything to share on this front?
Stephanie Geuns-Meyer
http://appft1.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PG01&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.html&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=%2220100189692%22.PGNR.&OS=DN/20100189692&RS=DN/20100189692
Jessica Green 200+
Glenn Barres
Take a building that is at least 3 stories with a good sized flat roof. The bottom floor is work space(offices and reception), middle is entertainment and lounge, and the third is living quarters. Now finding the right match of individuals and organizations to work and live in this space is important too. I will speak from my perspective but many different combinations could work. In my ideal settings it would contain my company, (a web development firm), a marketing company, a green tech company, and an urban gardening company(with farming and gardening on the roof). Combined these 4 companies could all support each other and for the most part be self-sustainable.
This concept can be extrapolated to the city block or even the entire city level with different combinations of co-living/working space.
Jessica Green 200+
Do you know of spaces that are currently designed this way?
Glenn Barres
I like the idea of being able to also learn from the study of these combinations. We would have to look at many factors including how an individuals stress level brought on by their daily tasks, the quality of air and water produced by the green-tech element, and the food produced by the farming element. Using the same types of microbes, ie, people/businesses, but where they each have a different approach would yield interesting results. Example: One urban farmer might grow more vegetables and another might grow more fruit and yet another might even have a large chicken coup. These small differences could have huge impact on the day-to-day health and vitality of those living within this space.
(I hope I am staying true to form in your conversation, please correct me if I am not.)
Comment deleted
Jessica Green 200+
Can you elaborate on what you mean by understand the structure/nature of the building blocks in our subways/houses/offices?
Do you have ideas on the types of clinical data that we should be suggesting to hospitals that they gather when we are gathering the architectural, environmental, and microbiological data?
Finally, it is my sense that both surfaces and air are important. What do you think common knowledge is about this?
Comment deleted
Jessica Green 200+
Something I have not discussed much in this conversation is that we know microbial diversity to varies from place to place within a building, and even from place to place within a single room. We are very interested in within-building microbial bioegeography.
I had never considered the spatial distribution of clinical data, and I did not know that hospitals collected this type of information.
Kirsten Webb
Jessica Green 200+
Jennifer Bingham
Gut Bacteria Know Secrets About Your Future by Robert Krulwich. It discusses the idea that people are in microbe sub groups like blood types and that these gut flora produce future outcomes such as being skinny or fat or if someone will develops ulcers or Autism.. Quite interesting if one day we can test our own set Gut Mapping to see what microbes hang out in us and what ones environmentally and benefit us. Well beyond just one probiotic strain.
Jessica Green 200+
Would you be interested to test your own home, or office, to see what microbes hang out around you?
Chris Aldon 20+
The farm purpose would be two-fold. First it would take a "swab" of incoming air and make an analysis of microbes living within (is that possible?)
Secondly the farm would grow microbes we determined to be helpful and release them in an even supply to the home or office.
Jessica Green 200+
I had not thought of the farm idea. Because we are still in the beginning stages of understanding how human host-associated microbes influence our health, it is not clear what types of microbes we would want to release. But the field is moving so rapidly, I can see this happening in the future.
Chris Aldon 20+
Hilal Eren
Jessica Green 200+
I wonder how those surface microbes influence the colonization of microbes indoors? I bet it would. The outdoor, surface microbes would like enter the building in a variety of ways.
Hilal Eren
Jessica Green 200+
Rachel Armstrong & Neil Spiller
Nature 467, 916–918 (21 October 2010) doi:10.1038/467916a
Published online 20 October 2010
Josh Schroeder
Let's look at a definition of probiotic (which I grabbed from Wikipedia): According to the currently adopted definition by FAO/WHO, probiotics are: "Live microorganisms which when administered in adequate amounts confer a health benefit on the host."
So you A) introduce something B) in sufficient supply, in order to C) benefit D) the host.
Perhaps using this rubric can help us ponder the topic of conversation:
Who or what is the host?
What is the desired benefit?
What or who is introduced to convey the benefit?
And how much or how many people are needed to make it happen?
Jessica Green 200+
Who or what is the host? The way I proposed the question, it would be the building. But there is a host within the host in this case. Because ultimately what most people care about is their own health. While we occupy buildings, we (humans) are contributing to the built environment "microbiome", and we are picking up microbes from the building. So there is an exchange.
What is the desired benefit? The desired benefit is to create spaces that are healthy for humans. An added benefit would be if we could design building that are healthy to humans, AND that have a reduced carbon footprint.
What or who is introduced to convey the benefit? One easy place to start is to introduce microbes that compete with potential pathogens.
And how much or how many people are needed to make it happen? I don't 100% understand this question, can you please elaborate?
Louvonnie T
Jessica Green 200+
Louvonnie T
Emory King
Jessica Green 200+
Do you have ideas about what might lead to an unusually high density of microbes within buildings?
Corvida Raven 100+
Jessica Green 200+
Jeff Babiak
Jessica Green 200+
I believe that we may be able to better control, for example, nosocomial (hospital-acquired) infections.
Do you feel that there would be an overall health cost to the general public if we were to reduce nosocomial infection rates?
Anrahyah Arstad
Jessica Green 200+
Anrahyah Arstad
Jessica Green 200+
When people think about microbes, they commonly think about harmful pathogens. In what context do you hear or think about "good" microbes, and how could knowledge about good microbes be spread?
My question for you now is more specific. What do you think it will take for people to recognize how much we rely on microorganisms?
Jennifer Bingham
Jessica Green 200+
Louvonnie T
Melissa Schmalenberger
Jessica Green 200+