TED Conversations

Ariel Ramirez

Frustrated psychologist,

This conversation is closed.

What is your take on what 'Psychology' is 'supposed' to be?

My field of study, if indeed it can be called that, has a rather, I would say 'confused' identity. As with any science that is relatively young, the only way to study something that we have little idea of, is to study what everyone else's opinion about it. On the objective cliff, the cognitivists, behaviorists, and experimentalists may maintain that we should treat it with cold calculation, critical reasoning, and impersonal analysis. On the subjective side of the cliff, we have the existentialists, humanists, and empathists that stand by the notion that we should look at it with an understanding and encouraging eye, that we as humans are far from 'robotic' machinations. There are, many other cliffs mind you, about as many as the perspectives that cast down an eye on the largely unknown abomination of a study that is psychology, with many claiming to be an expert of the same field, but of differing understanding. Even some people who have no background on the science can claim to be an expert in his/her own right. As such I ask, what IS 'Psychology'? What is this black void we all like to gaze upon but no one seems to be in complete agreement as to what it is. Like the blind men and the elephant.
Note: Please no copy and paste textbook definitions. In this science, as you read more books on it the more confusing it gets, at the same time everything would start to seem like a deja vu. Same concept again and again but no agreement, fascinating...


Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.

  • thumb
    Mar 2 2014: Ariel-

    The first email you send to anyone via TED has a 1000 character limit and you cannot attach files, and i doubt that images can be sent either. But this is for the first time email only.

    Once I get your first brief email, I can reply with attachments, photos (not many) and long messages, then you can reply with attachments, etc. too. I guess TED doesn't want strangers blogging another TEDster without being invited to do so by that person. I have sent out 2-3 emails via TED that the recipients have chosen not to answer, which is their right to do, of course.

    Again 1000 character limit, no images and no attachments.
    • thumb
      Mar 3 2014: ok, so ill send you my abstract then we can then exchange notes after. i've read about penrose and hameroff's hypothesis. I will reserve my opinion as of now but objective wise, isn't it alarming that none of Hameroff's hypothesis as gained from their theory has been proven right? only one resercher, a gentleman from japan had made conclusions that MAY be in support of Orch OR but nothing conclusive. I'm still reading the back and forth banter between penrose and hameroff vs their critics.

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.