TED Conversations

This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »

Does anyone care here about "sound pollution" and "mind pollution"?

Cause art/music appears to be doing just that... Music disrupts the sounds made by surrounding fauna making them loose their communication ways.

Music while listened by humans puts their brain/main in cycle of "boom-boom-boom/tra la-la" that goes for long time in the brain after session. All you can come up with after it is another "boom-boom tra-la-la". I never met a human that will say: "this song made me invent a new style wind turbine". Did any one?

Topics: art music

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.

  • thumb
    Jan 14 2014: well, Dorian, sometimes music can indirectly help you by letting your mind relax and go away from the problem it is occupied with. Or the lyrics or production can give you something to think about, or teach you something, and maybe lead to new thoughts, but they will only be thoughts related to those lyrics, or that production. But a lot of times I think it could interfere with creativity, it's very hard to think and listen to music at the same time.
    • Jan 15 2014: Once one man told me a joke:
      Americans ask Russians: "Y you drink so much?"
      R: "To relax. How you relax if not drinking?"
      A: "We do not concentrate so don't need to relax."

      This "relax" thing appears to be related only to the situation when you do work that you don't like to do. Mainly hurting yourself and sometime (if not all the time) others.

      Appears to me that 0.1% of lyrics in the best case make any sense. ~90% appears to be telling us that we like sex - but strange - we know that even before first experience.

      Creativity appears to be result of availability of tools and resources (including knowledge, passion, attention). From what I understand it shall not "concentrate" a human to the extent that he would need to "relax" - it shall be pleasure on its own.

      The only situation I C one may need "music to relax" appears to be when due unavailable tools/resources, or "orders from high ups that do not conform with ones view" make the one give up. As result one goes for any other information available that makes him forget his failure. Perhaps, instead of listening the music one shall search for solution that can be applied to real situation. Indeed our hierarchic society has plenty of such examples.
      • thumb
        Jan 15 2014: well, music appears to hold sensuous pleasure for many. The sounds are made to appeal to our ear and brain. Some like the chance to move and dance, music is interesting for them and brings out new movements. Some songs touch the emotions. Sometimes when you are working on something difficult, you need to get away from it for awhile, and music can be a way. What is your creative process, Dorian, what is your job and what do you create?

        I agree that listening to music could be wrong when you really wish you were doing something else, but don't feel empowered to do it. You have the impression that this happens often to people, right? What is your source on that? What is motivating this conversation, Dorian, are there people in your life listening to music and you think they are wasting their time? Or.....?
        • Jan 16 2014: At present days I do computer programming, playing with micro-controllers, take care of child, prepare food, do sports, question everything possible, talk with humans about economy, in particular Resource Based Economy as described by Fresco at www.thevenusproject.com, about non violent communication as described at www.cnvc.org, about book "Tyranny of words", learn 6th language (Chinese)...

          Art and as result music appears to be very powerful tool in informing human bran. However, it appears to be heavily misused. Just like alcohol - it can be used to sterilize wounds and medical tools or can be used to tranquilize brains. And all of this - to steal one of the most precious resources human has - his attention. As humans attention is busy with dealing with alcohol results, music cycles, games, bull-shit stories... human elite has their attention on planetary resources.

          By attention I mean in this context the process of focusing ones senses to a point in space and time.
      • thumb
        Jan 16 2014: well, Dorian, who do you know or where have you seen music used to tranquilize brains?
        • Jan 17 2014: Usually before elections in at least one country elites organize concerts on the main square o the capital. There one may see thousands of red faces screaming, some up to tears. By tranquilize in this context I mean "to disable the process of thinking". Does this anser ur question?
      • thumb
        Jan 17 2014: well, i've never been to such a concert. But how much screaming is there, or how long is the concert, because it would be exhausting to scream for two hours. But, Dorian, what do you mean by screaming, because people listening to music want to listen and hear pleasant sounds, they don't want to hear an ugly sound of people screaming continuously? Have you witnessed this personally? Where? Can you link any video that shows this?

        Sometimes you may not think overtly at a concert. You may only want to feel things, or dance, or enjoy pure sound. But still many may be thinking underneath it all. Also, after the concert, they may start thinking again, they may reduce their thinking during the concert.

        But I agree with you, people should not vote for a politician just because they put on a great concert? But if they like the politician's position otherwise, the concert may give them some pleasure and help them feel stronger in following that politician?

        But you are saying that a lot of people will vote for the politician just because they like the concert, the concert appeals to their emotions? But how many people attend the concert, 50,000, because in a national election, it takes more than 50,000 to put the politician in office. But what are you going to do, ban concerts, forbid a politician to have a concert?
        • Jan 17 2014: I'll tell you one case. The area I live is a block of few 17 levels buildings. Administration (that takes care of infrastructure) decided that we need music - and every evening we got music (everyday starting with Titanic song). I got tired of it cause it was loud and repeating and also depressing. So I wrote Administration a letter asking them to stop the music cause we, people who live here have enough devices to play our own music, and let bugs play their songs and meet and multiply, and let birds come (bugs are their food) and play their songs. Since birds do not play in cycles, its not boring and depressing (like Titanic) and reminds us the locals that nature is still there and is alive and is working.

          One single letter (I believe here have more than 400 apartments) - made them stop the music for already 4 months. Strange - but so far no one ask them to start it back - such impression that it was played for me in person.

          "...screaming continuously?" - those "emotions" you talk about - come to an extreme.
          "Have you witnessed this personally? Where?" yes. somewhere :). Go to rock concerts. "Can you link any video that shows this?" http://www.tudou.com/programs/view/LkE_ei0iagg/

          "You may only want to feel things...". 350 children die during "you may want" for 20 min from hunger - how is the filling now?

          "...people should not vote..." - Appears that "People should not vote! They shall solve directly whatever they think a "politician" shall do for them."
        • Jan 20 2014: re :relaxing and escaping are pretty similar...

          They are chemical cousins , yes, but they differ in degree.
          If you want to forget about your problems you try to relax ; but if you are aware that your problem is you, you may want to forget about yourself, you need much more to drink to achieve it, it's escape.
          Russians tend to opt to the latter...alas ! :)
      • Jan 17 2014: Russians drink not to relax but to escape, that's why they drink so much.
        • Jan 18 2014: Agree. Its also not Russians who drink the most. :)
        • thumb
          Jan 19 2014: relaxing and escaping are pretty similar, aren't they, natasha? What are you trying to say here?
      • thumb
        Jan 17 2014: well, Dorian, I really understand you not liking being forced to listen to music the administration chose. But at a concert, everyone listening has chosen to be there?

        Is there any music you like? When I watch the clip you provided, I see people enjoying the music, performance, and so on. It's not my type of music, but I can see how someone would like it.

        You seem awfully serious. You do realize people have to have fun, right? What do you do for fun? Do you think that for some people it is genuinely fun to listen to music, or are they all just faking it?
        • Jan 18 2014: Problem I try to analyze in this talk is not music - but overuse of it.

          Food one eats - brings him pleasure. Overused food brings him pleasure too - but at the same time fat and immobility.

          Alcohol - may cure and bring pleasure. Overuse also brings pleasure - plus brain destruction.

          Appears not to be the case that when U get pleasure you shall go for it. Drops of Venus flytrap (Dionaea muscipula) plant bring pleasure to a fly... and deaf.

          Pollution with CO2 does not mean that you shall not make fire ever again.

          Since children under 5 years still die from hunger at specified above rate - I fell uncomfortable and selfish to have that much fun as at the concert in the provided link. Or,, madona promoting presidents that bring war as well as gay marriage instead of - please find solution for famine.
      • thumb
        Jan 18 2014: well, how will you know when it's overuse, Dorian? Because you're saying that if you listen to any music at all, you feel guilty because children are dying of famine? The people at the concert, how do you know that is not the only concert they ever went to in their life? Maybe some of them are famine workers who work most of the time against famine, but just once they took two hours off to go to a concert? Then would you excuse them?

        Do you do anything for fun, then? What is it?

        Where do you live that you're so interested in starving children? Are there children starving where you are? How do you know they're starving? Have you ever seen a starving child? What are you doing for them besides talking on TED?

        You know sometimes musicians also fight for starving children? Some years ago George Harrison gave a famous concert for Bangladesh that I would think was supposed to help extremely poor people?
        • Jan 18 2014: 1. Those who die from famine are so slim that they cannot bring up from the ground their legs, hands and heads. People are results of environment - what I have to "excuse"?

          2. I live.

          3. On Earth. You? Not much - educate people about reality - check Resource Based Economy and Jacque Fresco talks on youtube for complete understanding.

          4. Yes some, very few do.

          PS: Overuse in case of music appears to me to be when the "global consciousness" aim in space and time does not meet my own needs due misdirection of attention of others from this Earth.
        • Jan 18 2014: In fact appears to be very hard to imagine how art/music may harm one. To have a deep understanding knowledge in Informational Physics appears to be required.

          A flying bullet may in-form (transmit its form, including energy) ones hand and cause destruction.
          A bee may in-form under ones skin its venom as as result venom chemical structure will in-form cells around.
          The same way sound in-forms (transmits its form from a sound generator INto abrain) the brain - neurons connect. It does not pain as in case of physical/chemical in-formation. However it affects ones next steps/decisions.

          Music appears to be ideology just like religion. And I already got named "atheist" in this talk :).
      • thumb
        Jan 19 2014: No, what I meant is that if you talked to the people at a concert, the audience, you may find that some of them hold jobs, pursue professions and careers, that are helping people around the earth. You might find people in the audience at a rock concert who, in their career and work life, when they are not at the concert, work at an agency for environmental improvement. You might find people in the audience, who, in their career and work life, when they are not at the concert, are working to reduce crime or drug and alcohol addiction. You might even find people who, in their career and work life, when they are not at the concert, work in agencies that fight famine. But, Dorian, most people cannot work 16 hours a day, seven days a week. In fact, if you only work, and work constantly, your productivity goes down, in fact you need to take breaks from work in order to keep working successfully.

        I would imagine many musicians give time and money to different causes. Do you think there are other worthy causes besides famine? What if someone were devoting themselves to fighting war, instead of famine? Would you accept that?
        • Jan 19 2014: At current level of technology - humans may not work at all - sadly they are blinded by music, tv and alike.

          Money - irrelevant solution. War is not to be started - not to fight. Questions you ask denote that you didnt check my refferences.
      • thumb
        Jan 19 2014: so you think humanity could live without having to work, except they are blinded by music and TV? That sounds very doubtful to me, Dorian. We have excellent farm technology, but farmers still have to work. We have excellent machines to help with making clothes, but humans are still involved in some aspects of sewing.

        Money is an irrelevant solution? Is money irrelevant to fighting famine? Then how do you fight it? Unfortunately, people do start wars, and then others work for peace, to end the war.

        I maintain, Dorian, that people cannot work 16 hours a day on making the world better, or solving problems. Sometimes they have to take a break and have fun. Well, there is some fun in making the world better, but there's a different kind of fun in listening to music, or dancing, or playing some basketball with your friends. Do you do anything that people consider typically fun, since you don't like the arts, perhaps you play sports, or watch sports, or....?
        • Jan 19 2014: Man - check Resource Based Economy and Jacque Fresco talks on youtube - all your questions answered. To understand why money are irrelevant check The Zeitgeist Addendum movie. To understand even deeper current economy - The Corporation and Food Inc, on vimeo: Capitalism - a lovely story. To understand how systems works and how they can be auto administered - you need to speak Russian :).

          I wish the world would be that simple and reduced to word "fun". Sadly appears not to be the case.

          For fun: If you want to "put me down" - come with real giants and climb their shoulders. (ask Isaac Newton why)
        • Jan 19 2014: Checkout http://www.usdebtclock.org/ how fast new money are created out of thin air. All of them go mainly on creating war.

          If your art reflects future planning - I'm all for it. If it reflects what you did yesterday with your girlfriend - I don't care,
      • thumb
        Jan 19 2014: what do you mean "put you down," Dorian? Do you think I'm criticizing you? I'm not, I'm just trying to understand your ideas and see if they are good ones.

        Well, I started watching a Jacque Fresco video on YouTube. He seems like a decent thinker. When you say art reflecting "future planning," what are you talking about? You mean like planning what you're going to do next weekend?
        • Jan 20 2014: By "put me down" - I mean change my view about music. I accept it may be possible but also suspect it may be very hard :). ... Anyway - it was mentioned to be for "fun".

          I mean "think globally - act locally". History does not matter - especially what nation hates who. Future matters - we are going to live there.

          If in a song/paint will be lyrics/images about futuristic ideas, about sociology, ideas heavily based on science I would accept it.
      • thumb
        Jan 20 2014: Oh, I don't have any strong agenda to change you, Dorian. In my mind, we are "playing" with ideas, do you accept that perception?

        I can see that your topic would be an important topic for music to take up. Is there any current music or songs that do this that you can steer me to? You got this idea about future planning from Jacque Fresco? Does he say anything about music?

        One problem I see is that if you limit all songs to one topic, the songwriters will become bored of the topic after a while, and write either bad songs, or no songs. And the audience is going to become tired of the topic after a while, too?
        • Jan 20 2014: Great! Now I can breath relaxed :).

          Songs I didn't encounter so far. There are poor attempts like Enigma's "The Same Parents"... Some artists also tried to put some Fresco's ideas on notes. But I'm not impressed so far. However a movie yes - "Idiocracy" - a comedy where a lot of aspects including monetary system and even music (army rock guitars) are shown from a little bit different point of view than today's standard. If you really like music - try to play/write songs - you'll learn faster it's aspects as well as limitations.

          Fresco mentions that "art is dangerous" since is "subject to interpretation" and also is "misused" by current establishment.

          Do not worry - with todays computer power and human stupidity "good" songs will only get "better" and their number will increase only.
      • thumb
        Jan 20 2014: okay, I will see if I can get a copy of Idiocracy. But Dorian, you cannot make every song about the same thing, people will get too tired of it. Even you will get too tired of it, I think?
        • Jan 20 2014: Hm... how it comes then that not so many get tired of present "love" songs?
      • thumb
        Jan 20 2014: excellent question, Dorian, I had not thought about it. Had you said that 90% of songs are about love? I think you are wrong, I think there is more variety than that.

        Can you write music? Maybe you could compose songs about your favorite subject, which is future planning, right? If you don't know how to write music now, maybe you can learn?

        Here is a study that shows 50-60 percent of songs are about love and personal relationships: http://news.ufl.edu/2007/05/31/pop-songs/ But, Dorian, even if you have excellent future planning, people are still going to be concerned about their lovelives and personal relationships, aren't they? Are you going to outlaw those songs?
        • Jan 21 2014: When a child like a computer game - it'll take tons of time to explain him why no need to waste time with it. He will understand it latter on his own. Appears to be I understood that about music :).

          There are amassing things out there to do. Especially when humans on street do not look down avoiding everyone and are ready to communicate with you with at any point.
      • thumb
        Jan 21 2014: Well, I don't think many people are going to perceive their love relationships like a computer game, people take love seriously and look for the best relationship and try to make the relationship better. Isn't that why people sing about their love relationships, Dorian?

        Do you have a love relationship with someone? But if you were a musician, you would not feel like writing a song about it?

        What is this mass of things to do? You mean talk with people on the street? What conversation are you going to have with them? But some of what you talk about with people is their love relationships, right?
      • thumb
        Jan 21 2014: just the conventional meaning, where you have some particular person that you particularly enjoy spending time with, probably have similar things you like to do, probably enjoy doing recreational activities together, there is a chance you will marry that person or are already married to that person, which means you have shared goals and probably some similar values, and can work together successfully? Also some sexual attraction.
        • Jan 21 2014: What if I can do that with many? What if marriage would be irrelevant anymore? Cause everything changes in space/time?

          What if everyone in the street would agree to do anything you offer from talk, to sports, travel and yes - including sex? What if you can have any means of transportation and you can stop anywhere on earth? What if you can travel anytime anywhere cause you can take a train that goes around earth in 4-5 hours? What if the technology would be that advanced that you can experience flying in the low moon gravity, go to Mars and alike? What if you can have access to any resource needed for any desired research?

          I don't want to "marry" anyone - or as one girl stated "we went and informed government that we sleep together".
      • thumb
        Jan 22 2014: Dorian, aren't you afraid if you just go with anyone you meet on the street, you might get AIDS?

        Actually, I think now people would talk to you on the street, but you would have to have a purpose for stopping them and asking them to talk? Do you see anyone on the street you would like to talk to, what would you like to talk to them about?

        I don't know, Dorian, seems like most people want marriage, no? Even though people know they don't have to get married. But whether you get married or not, you will still want to make music about love, won't you? Even if you don't get married, you will still probably only find one person or a few people who you want to be in a relationship with, and if you are happy in the relationship you might want to make music about it?
        • Jan 23 2014: One may be afraid to fly on this rock at 300 000 km/h with this hudge atomic reacrtor near by in the space full of other rocks, protonic stars that can kill us in seconds... I belive U know the joke that ends: "children - today we will teach u how to put condom on the globe".

          If to think in the frame of current established believes - what u say - makes perfect sence. However, 100 years ago - it would sound ridiculous.

          I'm talking about situation in which every earth's human knoledge would be brought to the highest level possible in the given moment in space time.

          According to my observations most of the long time run couples are not satisfied with their partners. And even old humans who start new relations - look more satisfied. Appears to be that we keep going together most of the time based on fear that will loose possetions or fear that no one else would accept us anymore.
      • thumb
        Jan 23 2014: well, let's say you do have a society where people move from one love to another. Still, is there anything wrong with celebrating love, after all you want to celebrate future planning in a song, why not celebrate love in a song?

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.