This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »
What creates greed? A response to a question on TED, I want critical, analytical, and honest opinions of the following answer, its of value.
I am fully aware of communism and those ideals are great! In theory... in practice they happen(ed) to be destructive, this is very true. However a greater debate could be on whether it is due or of the result; as being a product of the result it can be considered be to being economics. You cannot be equal when involving money .. So this will tie into greed. Greed (the want/”need” of power) is emotionally drived by being encouraged, responsibility-based, respect, honored, and influenced heavily through the ever changing cultures of time. This created a lot of our history, due to mass conquering(s) through out time, people trading, exploring, exchanging information in any form. This changed cultures, changed the way(s) many people think/live every century, sometimes never or rarely being effected. Very important, seen, and explored through(out) our ancient art, literature, pictures, pottery, paintings, and creative abilities to everyone through out human history. Everything effected, the way we are raised, the world in which we have to live our life in; remember life was lived differently throughout time and effected culture, faith(s) systems, and overall spiritual belief. Including to life; what our predestined jobs were going to be, whether we have options or not, what our opportunities are/what they aren’t, religious fundamentalism based belief system traditionalized into culture or freedom of religion.
Our fore fathers of science, philosophy, and math important to our modern day foundations of the sub-studies and the sub-sub-studies of these major subjects exist due to exploded, exploited, and enhanced study of these three major topics. Now there were very large populations of the world where people and entire cultures that were never exposed, associated, adapted, generated, inspired by alternative educations














Bob Van Oosterhout 20+
Comment deleted
Debra Smith 200+
Comment deleted
S.R. Ahmadi 20+
there is a Persian poem:
10 poor can sleep on a rug, but two King can not be fit into one kingdom.
Mark Meijer 100+
Why an addiction? Because we just can't seem to help ourselves, and we go to enormous lengths in our attempts to satisfy it. Any perceived inability to satisfy it (which actually is there all the time) causes fear, alarm, stress, sometimes even panic. And we actually experience withdrawal when we're not surrounded by the comforts and distractions that we've latched on to over the course of this never ending struggle.
Why an affliction? Because it constantly causes us to harm ourselves and others, and yet we never succeed in finding what we think we're looking for, much less being satisfied with it or deriving fulfillment from it. It dominates us to no end.
Why delusion? Because we keep thinking that what we are looking for can ever be found in the way that we imagine, despite evidence to the contrary.
Why pathological? Because delusion is defined as a vehemently held belief that is unsubstantiated or proven to be incorrect, as the result of a mental disorder, which is a psychological or behavioral pattern associated with subjective distress or disability.
Lindsay Newland Bowker 50+
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
I am not seeking for one answer but many, I am seeking to connect ideas to get a better foundation to where the problems in societies lie and so far.. the results are up in the air (but not in the clouds) and as this thread makes sub-topics in itself. I do not restrict thinking in terms of these answers but in search engines, articles, and academic journals. Every word thus far is copied into a word doc. therefore TED is where I find faith based ideas as well as factual considerations and even various mixtures. Rare on the internet when involving abstract topics, especially from those who enjoy thinking for fun!
Greed is no new subject at all Linday. But to think about the ideas surrounding greed is a greater benefit then actually figuring out what it is, personally.
Lindsay Newland Bowker 50+
E G 10+
Amily shaw 10+
Amily shaw 10+
do you think greed is prediposed in human ? or rather leanrt?or both?
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
So it is learned through educations to be called greedy and it is learned through educations to take the drives of surviving past to go surpass just surviving. Greed is the result of those who wanted the arm and not the hand. Greed is not natural unless it is needed to survive but then it is just survival and cannot be labeled, which as far as money is not the case but rather competition on some ridiculous level of materialism.
In short, greed was important to the world to evolve and change it, but today with our ever more "enlightened" and well educated people, greed is more and more frowned upon or more and more just a game to some.
So, yes (depending on education) and no to greed being predisposed to humans.
Amily shaw 10+
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
S.R. Ahmadi 20+
the answer is:
"doubt in God".
please go to Letters 49, 53 here:
http://www.al-islam.org/nahjul/index.htm
Greed is collecting materials more than need. and this is when a person thinks no one will protect him and no one will send him any free food and needs and himself alone should prepare needs for long time. but who believe there is some one always take care of him and send all his needs, then do not care about collecting materials more than need.
dear Amily shaw,
here is some more explanations:
http://www.al-islam.org/living-the-right-way/23.htm
http://www.al-islam.org/inner-voice-rizvi/38.htm
http://www.imamreza.net/eng/imamreza.php?id=3151
http://www.google.com/custom?q=greed&do_search=1&keywords=&cof=LW%3A245%3BL%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fal-islam.org%2Fred%2Fhtml%2F/images%2Flogo.gif%3BLH%3A44%3BAH%3Aleft%3BGL%3A1%3BS%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fal-islam.org%3BAWFID%3Acf808f8fa7f43aa9%3B&domains=al-islam.org&sitesearch=al-islam.org&search_type=on&sid=770480831
greed in Koran:
http://tanzil.net/#trans/en.sahih/89:15
http://tanzil.net/#trans/en.sahih/70:18
http://tanzil.net/#trans/en.sahih/89:17
Amily shaw 10+
natasha nikulina 50+
It is not deep insight into the phenomenon, just what lies on the surface.
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
Greed is good because it changed the world, it was important in history, is what I meant by my 6000 character essay. Now as we evolve in thought greed is more and more unacceptable and considered evil to be greedy. Natasha I am on your page no question.
natasha nikulina 50+
Debra Smith 200+
The second genesis of greed is self absorption and entitlement. When a child is raised without ever having to share and when they are convinced by caretakers and parents that they are very special and that all of their whims deserve to be placated - they become a specific type of greedy person who can never see that others have needs that are equally valid.
Revett Eldred 10+
The very word 'greed' has strongly negative connotations and so is, by definition, undesirable. I'm not sure you would find more than 0.0001% of the population who truly believe that unrestrained greed has anything good going for it. On the other hand, 'desire' or 'ambition' or whatever word you choose for a milder, less negative version of greed, is not necessarily a bad thing, as long as it is tempered by enlightenment. In fact, it is the driving emotion behind the creation of wealth, something that in general benefits all of society.
The 'greed' of the bankers has been thrown around a lot lately because of the bizarre derivatives market just before the economic crash. But would anybody particularly mind their greediness -- assuming they were, indeed, greedy -- if they had had to pay the price when the house of cards collapsed? Instead, governments around the world bailed them out with public money, and so all of a sudden their greed affected all of us. I believe the free market capitalist system is a wonderful system that creates wealth for all, but how can the system possibly work if we don't let the failures fail?
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
I will not get into capitalism, because among all the other ideologies in the world, none have done as much damage as that one.
the word greed is the focus, what it is, what enhances it, what creates it, and/or cause and effects.
Debra Smith 200+
EDIT: It could also be that you are simply entrenched in your viewpoint to justify your own dissonance.
Revett Eldred 10+
It is too easy to define greed as "that which I personally find greedy".
Debra Smith 200+
If you want evidence of wrong doing- how about Madoff and all of the bankers who obviously knew that it was a pyramid scheme but did nothing to protect the system or the investors.
Revett Eldred 10+
Your definition of greed seems pretty fluid and very much targeted at men in suits who break rules and acquire wealth "at the expense of others", but you seem to lump together huge numbers of such people with little evidence that all or even most of them did actually break any rules or do anything at the expense of others. If someone did, in fact, lie, cheat, and steal to become wealthy, I'm the first to agree with you that that is a pretty good example of greed. But just because someone was smart enough to assemble a complex paper investment that somebody else willingly purchased doesn't necessarily make that person greedy.
If you were selling your house and somebody offered you $50,000 over your asking price, would you take it or would you say "No, I'm satisfied with what I was asking, even though apparently I was asking less than the market price." If you take the money, you are, by your own definition, greedy. So now the difference between you and the billionaire banker is just one of degree, right?
Debra Smith 200+
Please see my other responses to you under the postings by Bob.
Bob Van Oosterhout 20+
The only way to have an ethical society is for each person to strive for an ethical life. I believe in finding a "fair price" when I buy or sell something and have paid more than the asking price and sold for less than the offered price when that does not seem fair. How can I expect others to be fair if I don't live that way myself. The satisfaction of a fair deal is much greater than a few (or even a lot of) extra dollars gained through dishonesty. The problem is that we don't have a system that reinforces this attitude. We have a system that reinforces greed.
Bob Van Oosterhout 20+
This is where the concept of "enlightened" self-interest breaks down for me. People with narrow vision of self-interest rise to positions of power and influence because that is where they put all of their energy and resource (greed). The failure of capitalism as manifested in the recent banking crisis is the failure to control greed. "Success" in business is evaluated in numerical terms which ignores relationships and the needs of others that do not directly contribute to the bottom line. I am all for freedom but freedom without taking responsibility for the effects of my actions on others is morally corrupt.
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
Revett Eldred 10+
But then you say you have a problem with the concept of "enlightened" self interest. Is it "enlightenment" you have a problem with, or the fact that many people aren't as enlightened as they should be? If the former, what then is your definition of that word. If the latter, no argument from this corner!
Bob Van Oosterhout 20+
Enlightened self-interest seems a contradiction in terms. I would think that an enlightened person would view his or her own self interest as no more important than the interests of anyone else. The concept of enlightenment comes from Buddhism which focuses on reaching a state of ultimate compassion and unity by letting go of the self which is seen as an illusion.
The problem I see with Ayn Rand influenced economic thinking is that it seems to disregard or ignore many of the effects of our actions on others. I must acknowledge I have not read her (but I have been thinking about it) but she seems to have influenced many of the politicians who seem less concerned about those who are affected by the economic decisions of the wealthy and powerful. They talk about the invisible hand of the free market but no one mentions that the free market also has an invisible heart (because it has no heart at all)
This brings me back to "enlightened." I would define it as one with a clear vision and an open heart. The market puts our world in a frame that only reveals what is perceived as good for those near the top of the economic ladder. I think that is a pretty small frame.
Comment deleted
Debra Smith 200+
Debra Smith 200+
My only orignal contribution to the giants of thought is to question, as a human being who my 'group' really is. Often, as a mother, I am advocating for future generations all around the world. These are the people who I believe are my group.
Bob Van Oosterhout 20+
I appreciate your respectful, open-minded dialogue with people who have different philosophies as well as your penetrating questions. I believe we have much more to learn from those we disagree with than from those who already share our point of view.
I think you touched on a key point when you mentioned Ayn Rand's belief that her philosophy is grounded in human nature. I have a different view of human nature and would like to see some discussion on that as well as on how to have respectful, enlightening conversations with people we disagree with.
I have a proposal for you. I will agree to read three books you suggest by Ayn Rand, Austrian Economists or others if you read 3 books I suggest that look at economics and human nature. I would likely propose "The Empathic Civilization" by Jeremy Rifikin, "The Fall" by Steve Taylor and "The Person and the Common Good" by Jaques Maritain.
If you are interested, we can discuss the details. One option would be to agree on a sequence and post regular comments as we read. This could be a process that could take a few months but I think it could be an excellent learning experience.
Let me know what you think.
Bob
Bob Van Oosterhout 20+
Bob
Lindsay Newland Bowker 50+
" I believe we have much more to learn from those we disagree with than from those who already share our point of view."
So much wisdom there and the key to tolerance..when we are willing to be present o what offends or annoys or displaeses or jjst doesn't agree with us..we are starting to get somewhere worth being....
Comment deleted
Debra Smith 200+
Debra Smith 200+
Comment deleted
Bob Van Oosterhout 20+
I guess no economist will ever get funding to study new economic systems. Technological advances provide possibilities that Any Rand and Adam Smith would never have imagined.
I will pick up a copy of Atlas Shrugged. Let me know if you want to start a conversation where we can trade impressions and questions for each other.
Bob
Comment deleted
Bob Van Oosterhout 20+
Sorry to be replying during this discussion but I could not find a listing for your email.
Bob
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
I appreciate all three of you making this so emphasized on my thread.
Lee Wilkinson 20+
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
Sorry this is the best I could do this, please figure the comment with no number is the second one.
Original thought provoked question "the core issue which is human greeds( not only in these who have agenda but also you and me and everybody).what do you think would be a good solution taking that into account?(with a sincere look)" - Amily Shaw
Your comment is most important.
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
Competitive drives transcend harsh physical laborer however to be a part of life.
Now through the entire academic system of education, 6 – 12 subjects of study at maximum have been covered, and all not equally. Morals are left up to the cognitive education in which involve reflective based cognition. In school by how your teachers treat you. Your parents: watching them - how they speak, how they talk, how they behave. Your friends: what it takes you to have them, what it takes you to keep them. All morally based. Now within all groups there is conformity to a degree, even if partial. Conform to area of world, life style, faith systems, ideas, ideologies, etc etc build friendship and bounds and increase education.
We have big problems today as a result of major greed that exist in this world. Money = power as it does throughout history, but inflation is most extraordinary in the most recent years than ever before. Now I hope by now it is clear where I am going with all of this? The idea of money is power. The human need for greed is drived by the emotional need to compete to survive. A “short-sighted” education is just that. Wise words “Education does not only encourage personal development, it also offers the general growth of an entire community providing a place for people to interact, socialize, and unify their societies”. People are greedy due to the competitive drive that is
Nicholas Lukowiak 50+
It is a part of nature in which human drives generate in nature naturally. Because of nature, the results of man, human nature recreated the human species time after time again, it is how we evolved into warriors able to be hunter/traveler/survivalist for thousands of years, it is how we win wars, it is how those who do not wage war are conquered, our natural conditions of being human remold and mold the world numerously over and over again. Competitive instant that keeps us going through life until an old age, longevity, is what kept us surviving through out life, thus the meaning of life, due to the laws of nature and universe.
I think its "short sighted" education that creates modern greed. What does academia teach? It teaches you to remember, practice, and reiterate. Cognitive education is what you have through out your life growing up. It affects the cognition in which a person develops their beliefs, morals, and ethics on. The world, in which a baby is born into, is a blank one, until they are a child when they can’t adapt to the surroundings and conditions in which their environment is set. There are rarely, seldom, or never a lesson on moral values in academic education curriculum, except from religious influence that comes from tradition of family heritage. So every child in the world gains education(s) through their lives normally those who(s) parents are any faith, religion, and belief holders their children will think in those worlds of thought; or a change of faith (certainty) has chance. Any challenges to faith in the majority of the world are rare. When confrontations, conversations, talks, and/or anything that suggest other wise to beliefs installed by society, family, or community t