TED Conversations

This conversation is closed.

Free will is circular reasoning

A is true because B is true. B is true because A is true (circular reasoning).
The idea of free will says "I caused myself to happen/act." Me causes me. My actions are caused by myself. My conscious actions are a result of myself.
If you ask why someone chose vanilla ice cream over chocolate, and they answer "it was my(A) choice(B)", they could also say "the choice(B) was mine(A) to make". Free will claims to be self-sufficient. Self-sufficiency is circular reasoning. "I chose(A) because I have free will(B). I have free will(B) because I have a choice(A)."
Options(A) makes choices(B) possible. Choices(B) are made when there are options(A) given.

Share:

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.

  • thumb
    Dec 26 2013: Before talking about whether Freewill exists or not, whether it can effect our choices over "chemically " or "mechanically" explained bodily reactions, PLEASE EXPLAIN WHAT YOU MEAN BY USING THIS TERM - FREEWILL.

    For instance, do you think that the power of Freewill might be physically "generated" somewhere in brains?

    Or do you believe in the existence of one's mind, which image is impossible for the researchers to see in brains?

    In our world of instant change must we, as the rest of all living creatures, keep choosing what to eat, grab, run from?

    How would we be able to survive without making our own, personal choices in our always personally unique sircumstances?

    In my opinion what we call FREEWILL to CHOOSE is deeply rooted in our natural mechanism of survival.

    (An individual might choose to follow others or find some special unique ways. Life ends when we have no choice. CHOOSING is the process of LIFE that no living creature can avoid! I trust this is how our belief in Freewill has been created.)
    • Dec 27 2013: Free will: the power of making free choices unconstrained by external factors.

      Choice: the act of choosing or selecting.
      Choose: pick out, select, or choose from a number of alternatives.

      Select: pick out, select, or choose from a number of alternatives.

      Pick out: pick out, select, or choose from a number of alternatives.

      These are the definitions given to me by a dictionary app by Clatin Software, LLC

      They all define each other according to these definitions. And this is one area I where see circular reasoning.

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.