TED Conversations

Robert Winner


This conversation is closed.

Has the US declared war in Libya, Somalia, and Pakistan?

This week the US Seal Team 6 invaded Libya and Somalia looking for terrorists. In 2011 President Obama took credit for the capture of Osama in Pakistan. These were in the words of the Defense spokesman conducted under the "Laws of War".

Wickapedia says Laws of War are: "The law of war is a legal term of art that refers to the aspect of public international law concerning acceptable justifications to engage in war (jus ad bellum) and the limits to acceptable wartime conduct.

Secretary of State John Kerry says: Terrorists 'can run but they can't hide': Kerry praises African raids while Libya demands 'explanation'. He recently declared Syrian President as a thug and murder. Is that some sort of diplo speak that I am not aware of. It could be that "fast boat" needs a few quotes to write himself a few medals. This should do it.

I just read the duties of the Secretary of State ... It did include that he / she is the chief diplomat for the United States. Failed to mention "Hawk in Charge".

Since Kerry is beating the War Drums for the Obama Administration ... who will be the diplomat that will seek peaceful resolutions to conflict?

I am not against removing the likes of Osama and captured senior al Qaeda official Anas al Libi. In fact I am all for it. I am against the US "invading" other countries and do it under "Laws of War" unless we have declared war.

How is this viewed by the international community. How about US citizens?


Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.

  • Oct 9 2013: Robert, Besides the convenience of the secret Navy Seal mission, it is also the problem of to whom you declare war. For example, When Osama Bin Laden made a sneak attack on the U. S., but he was hiding in Afghanistan, whom do you declare war on? Similarly do you declare war on Pakistan when bin Laden was there? Also should we declare war on Libya for Al Libi? Is it almost comical to declare war on Al Libi, then try to catch him on foreign soil?
    • thumb
      Oct 9 2013: Your point is well taken. The State Department spokesman stated that these were conducted under Laws of War .... not me. By definition the Laws apply at war. No war was declared ... so this was not authorized or sanctioned by the host country ... since they consider us terrorists and non believers .... was this simply a US sanctioned kidnapping ... a terrorist act on our part.

      The real argument here is: Does the end justify the means?

      They taught us at police academy that ... you cannot break the law to enforce the law.

      The real shame here is that we have lost international respect in foreign relations and are a diplomatic failed nation and getting worse by the day .... our domestic politics are no better.

      The Russians spanked us openly on the international scene ... we still defend Benghazi instead of correcting the errors and manning up .... while the USA is shut down we still give money to countries that hate us ... this could go on forever ... but like our leaders have said there will be no discussions and no negotiations (until the GOP gives in). Its my ball and if I cannot be the star I will take my ball and go home.

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.