TED Conversations


This conversation is closed.

Is our faith in the High Priests of Science misplaced?

The problem with ‘science’ is that it has been misplaced in the hierarchy of methods of investigating and understanding things, it has been incorrectly elevated to the role of the High Priest of knowledge and wisdom and as such, it has sought to provide answers where its role should be limited to that of observation, experiment and measurement. Is it this elevation of science to a level which it really does not deserve that tempts many scientists to act in dishonest ways to further or maintain their own professional or personal status within their own discipline within the scientific community?

A recurring theme of dishonesty and plagiarism occurs throughout the history of science in the work of people such as Ptolemy, Galileo, Newton and Einstein to name just a few. Is the dubious behavior of such figures a contributory cause or result of their iconic status? Is it surprising that if such iconic figures can engage in unethical behavior that ‘lesser’ scientists follow the trend? Why is science not sufficiently self-regulating and self-correcting?

Then moving on to more profound questions, we ask what damage is caused to Science by fraud, plagiarism and other unprofessional behavior? And, of particularly great importance, to what extent have these actions created false or flawed scientific paradigms and what blind alleys and over what periods of time have these possibly false paradigms delayed true scientific advancement?

Sadly, we do see in science not just a few bad apples but a systemic problem with misconduct. The following statement by Fanelli is shocking, “Among research trainees in biomedical sciences at the University of California San Diego 4.9% said they had modified research results in the past, 81% were willing to select, omit or fabricate data to win a grant or publish a paper.”This is the next generation of scientists who should be striving to maintain the highest levels of integrity in their chosen professions.


Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.

  • thumb
    Jun 13 2013: Mr Moody,
    Your comments on this question got me to thinking. Many polls have shown that too often there is cheating or, or, or generally going on in activities such as colleges, work sites, business offices even in grade schools. Not just science students but through out generational population. In my day, there was honor, even among thief's. Now days, honor seems to be old fashion, cheating to get ahead or to the top seems socially, morally and financially acceptable.
    It's not just scientist, it's politicians, corporate climbers, TV Evangelist, I think that the " I am there for me" attitude is all pervasive.
    • Jun 14 2013: I think, you are right, Science is not standing apart from anything else, nothing is.
      The mind that created religion is the mind that created science. The same way as religion betrays its Holy Doctrine science betrays its own Doctrine of Objectivity.
      Why ? I guess, Ego

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.