TED Conversations

This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »

Your beliefs on where Morality comes from?

C.S Lewis (Christian apologist) and Freud ("touchstone" to atheism) had opposing views on this topic, what are your views?

0
Share:

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.

  • thumb
    Apr 28 2013: Maybe it comes frome our genes, that human beings learned to do it over time and thus became heredity.

    But I think good morals should come from our knowledge that we are basically all the same. We are all human beings.

    Although I don't believe that criminals have any kind of good morals, at least who do harm intentionally.
    • Apr 29 2013: Tedor,
      "Although I don't believe that criminals have any kind of good morals, at least who do harm intentionally. "

      So you're good people and they're bad people? Is that it?
      Morals mean good and bad and are responses to ones environment.
      They are not necessarily indicative of a person "being a bad person", but a person who is responding to the threats of their environment in order to survive.
      If you have never lived in those kinds of environments you will not understand.
      Likewise, if you live by your comment, you will not understand either.
      You don't have to understand if you don't wish to but that is then choosing to remain ignorant and ignoring truth that exists and needs to be recognized.

      Experience is of supreme value in life.
      Good judgment comes from experience.
      Experience comes from bad judgment.
      • thumb
        Apr 29 2013: What I mean by criminals is people who kill other people especially, OTHER BAD BEHAVIOR CAN BE JUSTIFIED BY THE INVIRONMENT. And I mention INTENTIONALLY, that is by willing it and for no good reason.

        I don't believe there are good and bad people. I mentioned that we are all human beings. Moreover I believe that everyone has his circumstances.

        About morals, I think that good behavior should come from our knowledge that we all the same in a way and we should treat others as we like to be treated.

        I know that there are very hard enviroments that lead people to do anything, but I don't think that killing should be accepted!

        I treat all people with good morals. That's my judgement and it comes from my thought.

        What do you think? Please clarify if I missed any point of yours.

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.