- Uri Katz
- Philadelphia, PA
- United States
This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »
How do we make peace between Israel and Palestine?
Lets take it for granted that both sides are to blame in this conflict, and neither is going to disappear off the face of the earth any time soon.
Answers like "make love not war" would without a doubt work, but I am hoping for a little more substance.
If, like me, you think peace is only achievable in a distant future, but we have to begin working on it now, that is something I would like to hear, especially what we should be doing now.
If you know of a faster track to peace, all the better.
Closing Statement from Uri Katz
I would like to personally thank all the participants in this conversation.
I think we all recognized the immense difficulty this problem poses. At the same time, most people acknowledged that there is plenty that can be done, not all hope is lost.
Here are a few answers I collected. This is not a summary, only a list of the suggestions I think have the greatest potential to lead to peace. Each stands on it own, but together they have the most power. If we start implementing these ideas, sooner or later the reality in the region will change and a more direct path to peace will become apparent:
1. Instead of broadcasting yet another suicide bomber, give peace a chance by trumpeting every peaceful attempt by both sides.
2. Deflate the issue so that people see it not as cultural & religious issue, but as a localized dispute over resources and land. Then we can ask what a just division of these would be.
3. Recruit moderate religious leader.
4. Understand the other side as best as possible. How are they different? How we are they similar? Make sure your education is fact based and not propaganda.
5. Teach and practice forgiveness, which is key to all true conflict resolution
Also practice: Tolerance, Compassion, Acceptance, Appreciation
6. Remove all hate, and all us-them mentality, from school syllabuses.
7. Both side need to stop looking at themselves as victims. They are not victims of each other or of the larger world. They should take responsibility for their lives and actions.
8. The blame game does not help.
9. Historical arguments are usually used to advance one sided justification for violence and war, as such they are ineffective in the struggle toward peace.
10. Create joint projects such as competitive sporting events.













Ben Jarvis 50+
Sebastian Pérez
Ajay Doctor
This will keep both occupied more constructively and nurture human values. The "trading" will allow MOSSAD to be active too and offer a different perspective. Palestine will deter their own to live a more better and peaceful life and focus on opportunities to source, create and self employ.
UN too will be less exploited by the US & allies and optimize to do the real work.
shawn disney 10+
Anyway, if you want a fast track to peace, world government is it. Otherwise, we can continue to drift from one "Crisis" to another, until finally one nation conquers all. That will be, in effect , the same thing. The Chinese have had this experience, totally , 2000 years ago, before the First Empire.
shawn disney 10+
As to how knowledge of this might bring Peace, consider the brilliant advice of Pope John Paul: "If you want Peace, work for Justice". Exactly. The Arabs would forget about their burning hatred if they should ever get "Justice" But in the present political scene, no such possibility is even considered by the West and Israel. It is considered that either the Israelis won their war, and seized territory, Fair and Square, or alternatively, that the UN had the right to give away Arab territory without consulting the inhabitants. It is hard to reconcile either idea with the usual ideas of "Justice". So in the meantime, the Arabs are just saying, "the war isn't over yet".
Theodore A. Hoppe 200+
"The Balfour Declaration may be the most extraordinary document produced by any Government in world history. It took the form of a letter from the Government of His Britannic Majesty King George the Fifth, the Government of the largest empire the world has even known, on which -- once upon a time -- the sun never set; a letter to an international financier of the banking house of Rothschild who had been made a peer of the realm.
Arthur Koestler wrote that in the letter "one nation solemnly promised to a second nation the country of a third." More than that, the country was still part of the Empire of a fourth, namely Turkey.
Support for a "national home" for the Jews in Palestine from the government of the greatest empire in the world was in part a fulfillment of the efforts and scheming of Theodore Herzl (1860-1904), descendant of Sephardim (on his rich father's side) who had published Der Judenstaat (The Jewish State) in Vienna in l896. It outlined the factors which he believed had created a universal Jewish problem, and offered a program to regulate it through the exodus of unhappy and unwanted Jews to an autonomous territory of their own in a national-socialist setting."
http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v06/v06p389_John.html
http://www.mideastweb.org/mebalfour.htm
"There are different theories about why the British agreed to issue the Balfour declaration when they issued it. Some of these "theories," such as the claim that "Jewish money interests" were being courted to help float a loan for Britain or bring the United States into the war are racist inventions. Nonetheless the exact circumstances of the declaration are unclear. One possibility is that the declaration was deliberately contrived to allow the British to renege on earlier promises to France and the Arabs regarding Palestine. Lloyd George reportedly said that British control over Palestine would prevent it from falling into the hands of the agnostic atheistic French."
Theodore A. Hoppe 200+
There has been a good deal of discussion as to the meaning of the words "Jewish National Home" and whether it involved the setting up of a Jewish National State in Palestine. I have already quoted the words actually used by Mr. Balfour when he submitted the declaration to the Cabinet for its approval. They were not challenged at the time by any member present, and there could be no doubt as to what the Cabinet then had in their minds. It was not their idea that a Jewish State should be set up immediately by the Peace Treaty without reference to the wishes of the majority of the inhabitants. On the other hand, it was contemplated that when the time arrived for according representative institutions to Palestine, if the Jews had meanwhile responded to the opportunity afforded them by the idea of a National Home and had become a definite majority of the inhabitants, then Palestine would thus become a Jewish Commonwealth. The notion that Jewish immigration would have to be artificially restricted in order to ensure that the Jews should be a permanent minority never entered into the heads of anyone engaged in framing the policy. That would have been regarded as unjust and as a fraud on the people to whom we were appealing. (Memoirs, pp 736-7)
Albert Reingewirtz
Theodore A. Hoppe 200+
In the late-19th century, persecution of Jews in Europe followed by the creation of the Zionist movement, led to international support for the establishment in Palestine of a homeland for the Jewish people on the site of the ancient kingdoms. Following the British conquest of Syria, the Balfour Declaration in World War I and the formation of the Mandate of Palestine, Aliyah (Jewish immigration to the Land of Israel) increased and gave rise to Arab–Jewish tensions and a collision of the Arab and Jewish nationalist movements. Israeli independence in 1948 was marked by massive migration of Jews from both Europe and the Muslim countries to Israel, and of Arabs from Israel leading to the extensive Arab–Israeli conflict.[1] About 42% of the world's Jews live in Israel today.
Edmond de Rothschild financed two of the original settlements in Israel, Rishon LeZion in Tel-Aviv and Zikhron Ya’akov in Carmel. By 1934, the year of Edmund de Rothschild’s death, 125,000 acres of land and more than 40 settlements were purchased under the auspices of the Rothschild’s Palestine Jewish Colonization Association (PICA). Edmond de Rothschild became known as the “Father of the Yishuv” because of his involvement in early Israeli settlements.
Theodore A. Hoppe 200+
The British government decided to detach Palestine east of the Jordan river, constituting most of the area of Palestine, and form the Hashemite Kingdom of Transjordan, as shown in the map at right."
http://www.mideastweb.org/1922wp.htm
Ken brown 30+
Uri Katz
Albert Reingewirtz
Albert Reingewirtz
Arkady Grudzinsky 50+
Re: "I am a realist who read what is said by Arabs..."
All Arabs?
Arkady Grudzinsky 50+
What do you think of views like this: http://www.jpost.com/JewishWorld/JewishNews/Article.aspx?id=282661 ? Do they have public support in Israel?
Uri Katz
There will always be those who hate, and who use self-righteous arguments to support their hate. We need to focus on the moderates, and make sure their voice and actions speak louder!
Check this out:
http://www.ted.com/talks/israel_and_iran_a_love_story.html
Arkady Grudzinsky 50+
Interesting idea... Moderates need to speak louder... Moderation is an enigmatic concept. "Extreme moderation" is, obviously, and oxymoron :-)
Often, solutions to our problems lies in those self-refuting ideas like "moderation", "love your enemy" and "turn the other cheek". But it seems to be impossible to get them right.
Arkady Grudzinsky 50+
I have a feeling, this other quote may have a solution in it: "Do not resist an evil person. If someone strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also." But I do not understand myself how this is supposed to work in real world.
Pabitra Mukhopadhyay 30+
TO WHOM DOES THE LAND OF ISRAEL BELONG??
An Israeli Sense of Humor at the United Nations set the record straight.
An ingenious example of speech and politics occurred recently in the United Nations Assembly and made the world community smile.
A representative from Israel began: 'Before beginning my talk I want to tell you something about Moses:
When he struck the rock and it brought forth water, he thought, "What a good opportunity to have a bath!"
Moses removed his clothes, put them aside on the rock and entered the water. When he got out and wanted to dress, his clothes had vanished. A Palestinian had stolen them.
The Palestinian representative at the UN jumped up furiously and shouted, "What are you talking about?
The Palestinians weren't there then."
The Israeli representative smiled and said, "And now that we have made that clear, I will begin my speech."
prakhar porwal
the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and therefore
negotiators must take a close look at the land
swaps necessary for a negotiated settlement.
These maps outline three possible land-swap scenarios, followed by a map of the Geneva Initiative for comparison. The core principle of
these swaps is to reconcile the Palestinian
demand for a return to the pre-1967 lines with
Israel’s desire to include as many of the West
Bank’s 300,000 settlers in Israel proper as
possible. Any feasible scenario must include Israel's granting Palestinians arable land from
within Israel’s pre-1967 border in exchange for
annexed settlement blocs (clusters of
settlements). It is essential that, for any land
annexed by Israel as part of a deal, Palestinians
receive equal amounts of land.
shawn disney 10+
Jamahl Peavey
ZX Style 20+
In jeruzalem and other major cities, palestinians and jews can live in the same neighbourhoods.
So if they can in the major cities why not in the whole country?
What is required?
- palestinians should give up idea's on having their own palestinian state
- jews should give up idea of having a jewish state.
- make a new country call it Kanaan(biblical name of Israel when jews arrived after egypt)
- the new country is based on equality
And viola its done.
Where can i collect my nobel price?
Why is my simple idea not executed?
Jews believe with enough pressure they can eventually do anything they want.
Palestinians hope with enough screaming arab countries help invade israel and make it an palestinian countrie.
We as the world can say hey, now its enough it's a country for both, and man yourself up.
shawn disney 10+
The Loser would be honored with the responsibility. Perhaps for a fee, which would surely be less than the cost of the present "War", or whatever it is callled.
ZX Style 20+
But the problem is Israel as a nation is to powerfull to be held down by most nations.
So you need at least 2 medium sized countries.
That's likely why not much is changing now.
Kate Blake 50+
Albert Reingewirtz
Albert Reingewirtz
shawn disney 10+
Arkady Grudzinsky 50+
Albert Reingewirtz
Uri Katz
See this link for example of Muslims who do not want to destroy Israel or Spain (admittedly Persians, but we can find some Arabs supporting this cause as well): http://www.ted.com/talks/israel_and_iran_a_love_story.html. Making the mistake of letting Al Qaedai speak for all Muslims is intolerant.
Casey Christofaris 10+
Albert Reingewirtz
Uri Katz
I know there are plenty of atrocities elsewhere, plenty of holocausts and wars that have nothing to do with Jews. I also know that a conflict is extremely hard to understand from the outside. Darfur, Tibet, Cyprus, etc. are all sensitive issues and if there were 3 or 4 of me I could make a small effort to promote peace there as well.
To answer a few of your remarks: 1) Israel gave up more that its own size for peace with Egypt that up to this day has proven extremely beneficial to it (only time will tell what the new regime will do); 2) Not all Palestinians are evil terrorist, some of them (the majority I hope) just want to live full productive lives with their loving families. This is a fact so stop arguing about it! 3) Any route towards peace will have to eradicate terrorism, which has no excuse whatsoever, but its better to forgive and love than hate and fight. 4) Israel cannot put down its guns today, but wouldn't it be great if it could tomorrow. 5) My only shame is that it took me this long to start getting involved.
Juliette Zahn 50+
https://www.facebook.com/IsraelLovesPalestine
Uri Katz
Albert Reingewirtz
Uri Katz
Just a point to think about: assume I argue with my girlfriend because she blames me for cheating on here even though I did nothing of the kind. Let's say I was out buying her gifts and tending to the sick. She is 100% wrong, but I still have a choice of how to react and handle the situation.
Jamahl Peavey
Uri Katz
For my part, I was born long after all that, and I hate to harp on the mistakes of my predecessors, I'd rather focus on leaving the world a better place for my children.
Jamahl Peavey
There is no forward on a circle of violence and selective issues that should never be forgotten. Everything on a circle is backwards so we must learn and address the issues of the past.
Doris de Leeuw