TED Conversations

Arthur McQueen

This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »

Atheism: why do people don't believe in God?

My question to all atheists is that, why don't they believe in God? Can't they see His signs and can everything that happens on Earth happen by chance? If I don't believe in Allah, Jesus, Buddha or any other God, how can I live? I'll have no direction or paths.

Ok. I agree. There are somethings that we don't know about God, i.e. where did he came from but I believe there is a difference between the knowledge he possesses and we possess. If we'll get all that knowledge, what will be the difference between Him and us? There are numerous points where his knowledge is way better than ours.

If I don't believe in any God, then (I suppose) we are saying that everything that happens, happens by chance. What will be the purpose of living then? Other than living for the betterment of the people, is there any other reason for living? We already live in such chaotic conditions, so isn't it better to die in this case?

Now, I am not trying to hurt anyone's feelings (and if I have done that, I apologize from the depths of my heart) nor am I saying that atheists should die or have no reasons to live but I still find it difficult to NOT believe in God. Thank you.

+2
Share:

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.

  • Sep 12 2012: "Can't they see His signs and can everything that happens on Earth happen by chance? "

    "If I don't believe in any God, then (I suppose) we are saying that everything that happens, happens by chance"

    Arthur, im assuming that you believe in a God that can interject and control the chaos that ensues on earth? If you believe this to be so wouldn't this make God evil? For all the hellacious and depraved acts that humans exact on our own and other species, who could really claim, that if God was in total control, he is just and loving?
    • thumb
      Sep 12 2012: There is a pleasant glow when you show up Brian.
      Just to paraphrase;
      If God controlled everything he would be a dictator.
      He left us with a free will.
      Some mess we are making, just by showing up at this site of His without any solutions.
      Until soon,
      Aware of and caring about you All.
      Don [From The Silent Generation - 1930's]
      • Sep 12 2012: Don, good to hear from you my friend. You are right if God controlled everything he would absolutely be a dictator, an especially evil one. Free will is an extremely debatable and relatively divisive issue that many people cherish. The idea that one has control over there behavior and actions seems pleasant, but doesn't hold water in my opinion. Control is what humans strive for, we yearn for it, yet control is another illusion aimed at keeping fear at bay.

        From my perspective humans naturally bamboozle themselves in order to replicate our genes and continue living as creatures who have gained a higher consciousness and an understanding of their imminent death.

        When the world does not make sense it causes great distress and anxiety. It is far easier to make up an answer to which we have no empirical evidence for than it is to relinquish our pride and show humility. I don't claim to know if we have free will or if God exists i do my best to objectively look at the evidence for both sides and when I do i find a literalist interpretation of religions to be asinine. When i step back and look for beautiful metaphor i can also find it alive and well in some religious texts.

        My point is that religion is not meant to be taken literally it is meant to be a guide in a world where many different roads leads to self destruction, unfortunately religion can be one of those roads if one gets lost in the mist of blind belief, superstition, and obsession.
        • thumb
          Sep 15 2012: Brian I really like what you said. Especially about taking things literally, which usually means the end of it all. It does not take much for people to screw up the best things in life (or this world).

          Here is this part of a book that tries to explain how a God would work and keep things around us, and inside us, under control. There are a good number of questios here that you may be familiar with or feel as appropriate.

          Very much wonder what you think about it.
          http://webhome.idirect.com/~abraam/documents/Permission.pdf
    • thumb
      Sep 12 2012: Well, actually, if there was an omnipotent and omniscient god, even if not in total control, given the magnitude of things that happen, this god would have to be from indifferent to callous to beyond sadistic.
      • thumb
        Sep 12 2012: Hi Gabe....No dichotomy in God. Humans, yes
















        1
        • thumb
          Sep 12 2012: Oh that's right. God is not dichotomous. It is the Devil.
        • thumb
          Sep 12 2012: Hi Helen,
          I did not say anything about dichotomies.

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.