- TED Book Chat
- New York, NY
- United States
This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »
Discussing "The Science of Radical Life Extension" with TED Books author David Ewing Duncan
Continuing with our series of TED Book Chats.... How long do you want to live, and why?
For the next two weeks, we'll be discussing David Ewing Duncan's new eBook, "When I'm 164", on the science of radical life extension. Duncan surveys the increasingly legitimate science — from genetics and regeneration to machine solutions — and considers the pluses and minuses of living to age 164, or beyond. We'll look at everything from the impact of extended life on cities, services, and the cost of living as well as what happens to love, curiosity, and general health.
The book is available for Kindle, Nook, and iOS devices (which have a great new custom TED Books app):
Kindle copy: http://www.amazon.com/dp/B008XB16ME/
iOS app: http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/ted-books/id511071050?mt=8
The New York Times also published an excerpt this week, you can read it here: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/26/sunday-review/how-long-do-you-want-to-live.html
Finally, author David Ewing Duncan will be joining us for a live Q&A at 4pm EDT on September 11th!
Looking forward to our discussion!













Aja Bogdanoff 20+
Kevin Joiner
Andrew Davies
What thoughts do you have on how your argument relates to euthanasia? Is wanting to live longer just the same thing as wanting to choose when you die?
Thanks!
Andy
David Duncan 20+
Sean Conner
So my question to you is, what exactly (or not exactly) do you think bothers you most about having your consciousness in a machine?
David Duncan 20+
Sean Conner
Kevin Joiner
David Duncan 20+
Kevin Joiner
Michael Twentyman 100+
Jess Lyo
David Duncan 20+
Aja Bogdanoff 20+
katey moore
David Duncan 20+
Aja Bogdanoff 20+
David Duncan 20+
Aja Bogdanoff 20+
Anyhow! Sorry for the digression, apparently that movie made an impression on me. :)
Robert Sagal
Would a 60 year old in 1912 have looked as old as an 80 year old today?
David Duncan 20+
Aja Bogdanoff 20+
Sean Conner
For me, I'd like to have several phases to my life extension. First I'd like to try living in my organic form for another 50 to 60 years - perhaps with increased faculties, or small augmentations. There is a lot of experiences that the current normal life span has that I think I'd really like to experience. Such as having and raising children.
Then I'd like the opportunity to transfer my consciousness to a machine, perhaps with a mechanical extension that allows me to venture into parts of the planet and solar system that are impractical and too dangerous for organic forms to go.
This is getting away from the original question, but after that - maybe a 1,000 years of exploring these axises of experience - I'd like to opportunity to experience time differently, on the scale of 10s, or 100s of thousands of years.
Then... I don't know what. I find it difficult to fathom what type of thoughts and desires one might have at that point, after experiencing so many things. It may be the case that the infinite complexity of the universe is enough to explore until the universe ends, or it may be the case that there is not infinite complexity and I've explored and experienced everything and there is nothing more to do, and thus end the journey there? Who can say.
Fascinating question!
David Duncan 20+
Karen Zusak
David Duncan 20+
Alan Broughton
David Duncan 20+
Alan Broughton
David Duncan 20+
Aja Bogdanoff 20+
David Duncan 20+
Aja Bogdanoff 20+
David, welcome to TED Conversations, and thank you for sharing your busy time with us! I loved "When I'm 164", what a great overview of such a thought-provoking field. You raise such interesting questions... can we radically extend our lifespans? Should we? What would the world look like if humans lived twice as long as they do today?
I have many questions, but I'll start with the basics: How did you get started researching extreme aging, and how long have you been working on it? Was this a professional or personal interest?
Thank you, looking forward to the next hour!
David Duncan 20+
To answer your question, I approach this issue as a journalist and communicator who has spent years reporting on amazing life science tech, and asking the question: what are the implication of new discoveries? In this case, it struck me that the biomedical enterprise is producing what one scientist called a "side" effect of extending lifespan. What does that mean to individuals, and for society?
W. Ying 10+
If we live forever, we will be happy never.
Sean Conner
I love my life, but it wasn't always this way. If my life ended at say 18 years I might have only known melancholy, frustration and disappointment - never having the opportunity to explore different aspects of myself, traveling the world, trying new things, inventing, trying out new careers. If I could do this for another 120 years for me it would be a great blessing.
So while I see the point you're making, I would be inclined to say it can go either way. If you're happy more time would be a gift. If you're unhappy more time might be a curse... or it might be an opportunity to learn to be happy.
John Shaw
Kyle Chasse
Jess Lyo
Kyle Chasse
As for cancer i know several people with promising procedures including stem cells and nano-technology... soon we will be able to treat all disease...
Sean Conner
All of that said, I've always been conflicted by the nature of these "life challenges." On the one hand I pity the untested, unchallenged life. The life that will face no great challenges probably isn't a person with a lot of depth of character. It seems like the most interesting, empathic, daring, and accomplished people I've met have faced great challenges in their life.
That said, however, I would never wish these dramatic, painful and life changing experiences on anyone. So I think this is where my conflict comes in. How should we process these experiences; as an opportunity, or as victims of a tragedy, or both, or maybe as something completely different?
What do you think Jessica?
Miguel PEZ
I am positive nobody has really thought seriously of what it would be like to live forever. Forever.
This obsession is driven by fear of death. No acceptance of our mortality.
It is a matter of quality over quantity for me.
Valerie Tate
My mom is the only person I know who wants to live forever.
Luke Hobbs
Scott Bedingfield
There are many moral, ethical, and environmental implications of this reality. Perhaps chief among them is the potential for accelerated resource depletion, as mentioned previously, a scenario with dire consequences. Peering further down the road, given increased competition for resources, there is a very real possibility that humans could speciate between enhanced and naturals in less than a millenium, particularly if the current trend of wealth disparity continues. Speciation would no doubt be accelerated if enhanced humans have significanlty expanded life spans that allow for more off-spring and the opportunity to multiply current material advantages for future generations.
It is easy to imagine doomsday scenarios; we are predisposed to fear the unknown. The challenge is to imagine and elucidate a positive future where these capabilities are used to alleviate suffering, restore a verdant planet, and allow us to reach the highest expression of what it means to be human.Just think how you would live if you knew you were going to live to be 150 or more. And it may be that the full extrapolation of human life extension means having a body may be optional or even intermittent. Envisioning such possibilities is a good use of the intellectual stimulation provided by doomsday scenarios.
Personally, it seems like I'm a slow learner. I could make good use of a life span of 150 years or so. All men die; not all men truly live.
Louise Nelson
1. When I can't brush my teeth by myself any more it's time to go. and
2. I'd prefer to die before I run out of money. I doubt that my retirement investments + social security payments would keep up with the cost of living, never mind high-tech life extending interventions.
In general I wonder: How would retirement laws and benefits change? For example, would Social Security or pension payments end after 25 years? Would people just not retire unless forced by ill health? Would people of all ages, instead of thinking in terms of retiring after a long stint in the workforce, take a year off here and there to recharge, re-think priorities, or just coast for a while?
Jon Ho
What if, through the magic of gene splicing, you can be young forever, and keep working for money? There will come a day when you will feel so tired, that life has stagnated into an unchanging drudgery, that everything is the same every single day, that death is the only means to escape the monotone.
And then, at the exact moment you die, you will realize: Life is Beautiful. Without death, you will not recognize this simple precept. ;)
Louise Nelson
You sound as if you've never been on the end of the income scale that many former middle class US and EU residents have joined in the past few years. There are millions living "paycheck to paycheck." I know a fair number of people who work 40 hours/week or more and still have no benefits - no health insurance, no retirement savings, no vacation or sick time. Some of them are working for one employer, but as a part-time employee in more than one department. Some are working more than one part-time job and some are government contract short-term employees.
Here in the US even a middle-class income can't provide for the cost of a chronic illness - another fact I've learned through personal experience with multiple sclerosis, bipolar disorder, and multiple food allergies in my family.
daniel hehir 20+
The one evil would lead the human being away from all the earthly toils and tribulations. Away from what mankind has to deal with and work out to improve the lives of their brethren and fellow man / woman. Not really care about others and their suffering as long as I have a good time here as long as it lasts.
The other evil would bind the human being and its soul forever to the material. Bind his body and his soul to earthly existence as much as possible. Convince mankind that this is all there is ...that there is no afterlife.
The second evil is what we are talking about here.
Ed Schulte 50+
How is Spain treating you?........the old hang out of John Yepes no less!!
OK you have touched on the negatives of "I don't want to die" and what that mentality also wants to continue doing.....I call it the "take what you want and burn the rest" mentality
But lets not over look the "something" else here.
When one lives in the consciousness which is opposite to what you have ID'd then........similar BUT different to the "I don't want to die (mortally) " and that is accessing the potentiaal every HUman BEing has of re-creating the material/physical body ....'At Will.'
Since there have been Attained BE-ing of past who have demonstrating this potential ...(one has caused a current Religion to be generated out of his simple teaching) could it be that what we see in "when I am 164" material, and cosmetic surgery and body freezing and and "Fountain of Youth" seeking.....ect etc .....to know this potential Sub-consciously ( learned / taught / reminded while living in the Psychical / Noetical ) but not being able to resist Ego downward (the negativities) pull ??
This is nothing but a review of Goeth's Faust of course but since this started as a book review ..what the heck!!!
daniel hehir 20+
Goethe does have some relevance / influence ... yes!
I did however just start a new discussion under questions. The first one in a long time. Check it out.
What do you know about crop circles ..??
daniel hehir 20+
Bob Dylan said that.
I would like to live a long long time, but I don't ever want to get old ......
I said that ......
Kate Blake 50+
Anne Thull
So far the drug companies accept death-side effects of drugs as a norm- this is not acceptable. We will need these in addition to the advancements in genetics
As we grow older and the people of our generation die off, we feel more isolated.
That's what I have observed of Grandparents and my Parents generation.
Most of them are ready to go when it happens but they don't wish to cut it short.
I think we are putting too much emphasis on 'this life' and not exploring the next - that's the real ride!
Lacee Sherman