TED Conversations

Imad Atwi

TEDCRED 10+

This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »

Is the the impact of public opinion or grassroot movements increasing throughout time and how much should we count on it?

Do people know what is best for them?
Does a happy nation signal the maintenance of a status quo?

0
Share:
progress indicator
  • thumb
    Aug 19 2012: The primary thing we need to know is that public opinion is manufactured. I once developed poll questions. I can get what ever results you want by wording the questions properly. During election years the polls are really off. You answer the phone and the question immediately decides if you want to talk or not. So you only get one side of the picture.

    Grassroot movements are still great but no longer have the impact they once did. Lets talk schools. You want to make changes. You can elect school board members but they are more and more just paper tigers. All decisions on the educational process are made through the legtislature and the federal government. The real elephant in the room is the textbook printers. They are a multi-billion dollar industry. The feds and state legislatures control the money and that is the bottom line. He who has the gold makes the rules.

    I personally think that most people have lost faith in the system and have become part of the silent majority. I understand what the problems are and have learned what the limits are in attempting resolution. Say you have trouble with a teacher. You can (maybe) talk to the principal. Have you ever been informed of what was done to resolve the problem. No. The doors slam shut. Most of that is due to the power of unions and the unions threat of law suits. Due to tenure and unions problems can go on for years.

    Media coverage is both good and bad. They give credability to causes like no prayer in schools .... but they can also bring issues to light that need community support. The problem with media is that in the last few years thay have stopped reporting the news and entered the political arena and begin shaping opinion toward their point of view.

    Stop being a sheeple and do your own research into all things. Get involved.

    All the best. Bob.
  • Aug 15 2012: If one can be sold soap, soup, or whatever they can be misled about the issues,what they want, what someone stands for, etc. etc. REality can be a very tenous thing. Economically the United State has structural problems. Americans are being given a choice Between Obama's fiscal solutions or Romney's fiscal solutions. Can we really deal with the true problems? No. Maybe the bubbles have to burst just like the S&Lproblem, the realk estate problems, ENron, etc. etc.
  • thumb
    Aug 13 2012: One thing which seems to be changing over time is how we use technology to communicate.

    What started as the few writing for the few, moved to the few to the many and is now moving towards the many speaking to the many. Though of course the technology is still controlled by the few.

    Another big change is that we now see and hear more about our friends, and friends of friends, than we hear about the powerful. This must surely influence how millions see the world.

    There should be more opportunity for grassroots movements. And the people in those movements should have more access to education and information.

    So we should hope that there is wisdom in the crowds that change society.
  • thumb
    Aug 13 2012: Most people do not know what is best for them. That's how you get things like an economic system that enslaves all who are part of it, or an educational system designed to keep students ignorant, or a political system that is designed to keep people out of their own government, or religions that keep people afraid even though fear-based decisions are always self-destructive.

    Do not count on grass-roots political movements because they support and encourage the corrupt political model they are trying to work against. You can only hope that more people will awaken from their slumber (delusions) and you can only awaken into freedom. When you awaken, you will no longer fear the sheeple or their rulers.
  • thumb
    Aug 13 2012: Of course people know what's best for them. Talking as if they don't is highly egocentric and, if followed up with legislation, leads to dictatorship.

    If you want democracy, then you cannot force people to live a certain way. Warts and All.

    A happy nation would indicate stability, justice and equal opportunity. If the status quo revolves around these things, then yes, it would be indicative of maintaining the status quo.

    I also think this is easy to achieve for an individual and becomes far more complex for a society.
  • thumb
    Aug 12 2012: Unfortunately there are a lot of sheep out there. Sheep, as in people who don't think for themselves.

    However, I think there's a larger, growing population of people who can think for themselves, due to an increase in quality of education over the years.