TED Conversations

David Roemer

This conversation is closed. Start a new conversation
or join one »

Materialists and those who think humans evolved from animals are irrational.

The human mind is structured like the scientific method. At the lowest level, humans observe things. This requires paying attention. At the level of intelligence, humans ask questions and invent possible answers. At the level of reflective judgment, humans marshal evidence and decide what is true or just probable. The next level is free will, that is, deciding what to do with our bodies.

Materialists say animals pay attention and are intelligent and rational. They don't say, however, that animals have free will. What they say is that free will is an illusion.

Related Talks:
+1
Share:

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.

  • thumb

    David Roemer

    • 0
    Aug 7 2012: Humans create an infinite number of sentences. What is meant by the word "infinite"? We can comprehend what a human is because we know everything we do and everything that happens to us. But we can't define or explicate what a human is. Humans are indefinabilites that become conscious of their own existence. In other words, humans are embodied spirits. Another way of saying this is that the human soul is spiritual.

    Evolution is the study of the evolution of the bodies of humans, not their souls.
    • thumb

      Stewart Gault 30+

      • 0
      Aug 7 2012: That's only with the premise that humans have souls, which theres no evidence to suggest actually exists.
      And a homo sapien is rather easy to explain I'd guess a quick wikipedia search would give a good explanation.
      Also this does nothing to affect the fact of physical Evolution, I'd suggest you maybe change your theory to, at some point humans got souls put into us and that's why were special or something like that. Whether by divine intervention or a soul gene whichever you prefer

Showing single comment thread. View the full conversation.