Trevor Howard

This conversation is closed.

Can we restore salmon runs without hurting our economy?

Salmon are the lifeblood of fisheries in the Pacific Northwest, yet they have been in steep decline ever since Euro-Americans settled in the region. Up and down the West Coast of the United States, the past decade has seen a number of unprecedented collapses from the Sacramento River in California to the Kenai River in Alaska. Various reasons from over harvest to voracious predation have been cited as reasons for this collapse but seemingly the largest reason is a loss of spawning habitat. In a nation that relies upon dams and logging to sustain its population, are there feasible means of restoring these runs to their historic strengths without disrupting the economy? Also, do you believe the removal of large dams like the Elwah, Klamath and Snake River dams will benefit both humanity and the fish?

  • thumb
    Jun 25 2012: I sure hope so! i love the stuff and most people need more omega threes.
  • Jun 14 2012: The excuse ot the economy is becoming very monotonous, one can't be without the other. however the fisheries and wildlife service over your way, sorry we call them something different over here, are doing some fantastic inovative things on your dam areas, things like fish lifts and fish highways, they are on youtube for a quick snap shot. So even while the economy is important the service is also trying to work out ways to combat this depletion. there work is now spreading worldwide for other dams sites and threatened fish species. There is hope
  • thumb
    • thumb
      Jun 12 2012: I understand the fact that fish ladders can be useful in aiding fish migration upstream, but juvenile fish rarely use them when they move downstream. Typically, dams still provide a massive barrier as juveniles either swim into turbines or are dumped over a massive spillway that opens them up to severe predation and very significant losses of migrating fish over time.
      Not to mention, dams significantly alter the natural flow regime of a river while also blocking the downstream movement of sediments like gravel that are necessary for salmon spawning. Fish ladders, along with hatcheries were thought to be the solution, but it has become apparent that they are not enough.
      • Jun 14 2012: maybe not enough but they are a step in the right direction,