- Devin Tarr
- Chico, CA
- United States
Master's Student, California State University Chico
This conversation is closed.
Why should presuppose that the cause of religious experience must be natural?
As I was watching Mr. Haidt's talk, I was struck with what he categorized as the "million dollar question". He says:
"Is the staircase a feature of our evolutionary design? Is it a product of natural selection like our hands? Or, is it a bug? A mistake in the system . . . religious stuff just happens when the wires cross in the brain?"
It seems, considering the testimony of those having such experiences, that we should at least consider whether they're caused by a super-natural explanation. It struck me as odd that Mr Haidt's logic went like this:
1) People have self-transcendent experiences, through religion or other means
2) What could be the cause of these experiences?
3) They must either be a natural feature of humanity, or a delusion producing bug in our biological system.
It seems to me there's an obvious third question as well. Is there something beyond us (super-natural) that we're connecting to, or is connecting to us.